Page 29 of Only for Tonight

My abs start bunching, my body shaking, and my toes curl. “I’m going to come.”

“Come, Baby.” He leans down and bites into my shoulder.

“Toby!” My balls draw up, and cum starts landing on my chest, chin, and lips. Toby’s got me bent so far in half that I almost came in my own mouth.

“Fuck,” Toby half groans and half moans. “Baby.” He pulses inside me so hard that I can feel him coming. He gently lets my legs down and lays on my chest. “That was intense.”

“It was.” I run my fingers through his sweaty hair, and he sighs. “But it was awesome.”

“Fuck yeah. We need to do that again.”

Jace chuckles. “I think we need to let him recover from today. He’s got to be sore.”

“I am,” I agree.

“You agreed to be ours, Baby. Did you mean it?” Toby looks at me with such hope that I peck his lips.

“I did. You just have to be patient with me. Sometimes, I freak myself out.”

Jace pops his head over the top of the couch and kisses me upside down. “If you’ll let us, Angel. I want nothing more than to show you off.”

I take a deep breath and throw caution to the wind. “Okay.”

Toby and Jace kiss all over my face, making me laugh. I feel deep in my soul that we were made to meet that night, that we’re meant to be more than fuck buddies. I refuse to let my dad’s hateful words tear me down.

“What the fuck is going on?” Toby’s head jerks up at the voice.

“No time like the present,” Toby mutters and pulls me to sit up. “Meet the third mask.”

He sweeps his arm toward the entryway to the living room, and all the air leaves my body when I see who’s standing there. I push against Toby’s chest until he lets me stand up. “What the hell is this?”

“Baby, what’s wrong?”

I don’t take my eyes away from the newcomer because it’s none other than my sister’s ex-boyfriend. The one I had a crush on, the untouchable one, who dated my sister for two goddamn years. “What is this, Aiden?”

He runs his hand through his curly, dark blond hair. “You weren’t supposed to find out yet.”

“Find. Out. What?” His voice. That raspy tone, the cologne, the scar on his chest. It all starts slamming into me. “Holy shit. It really was you.” Toby reaches for me, and I stumble backward. “You knew it was me! How could you?!”

“Someone better start explaining,” Jace demands.

I whirl on him. “Like you don’t fucking know. I feel so stupid. I want to go home. Now.”

“We have no clue what’s going on right now. Do you two know each other?”

I feel my eyes starting to tear up. “He used to date my sister. The only person who’s ever had my back, and I fucked her ex.”

Jace glares at Aiden. “You knew?”

Aiden throws his hands in the air. “Yes. I fucking knew. When I saw him on the site, I knew I would finally get my chance. This is why I told you guys to stay the hell away from him. I needed to figure out how to tell him.”

“Your chance?!” I yell. “You used to FUCK MY SISTER! Oh my God. I need to go home.” I feel my heart breaking for doing something so horrible to my sister. She’s the only one who’s ever been there for me besides Leland, and this is unforgivable. “How could you?”

Aiden steps forward, and Toby stands in front of me. “Stay the hell back.”

“I can explain.”

“No,” I shake my head. “I want to go home. I can’t do this.”

---