Page 26 of One is Never Enough

“Toby,” Oliver moans, looking up into Aiden’s eyes. Goosebumps are lining Aiden’s skin, and his dick is pushing against the cock cage. “Can I take the gag out?”

“Yes,” I answer, thrusting my fingers inside Toby. Oliver pulls the gag free, and Aiden’s panting for breath.

Toby braces Oliver’s foot on the shelf beside Aiden, putting them chest to chest. “God, you’re gorgeous, Darling.”

“You like seeing him tied up for you, Baby?”

“Fuck yes. Can I touch him?”

“Tease the fuck out of him, Cum drop.”

Oliver licks up the scar on Aiden’s chest, making Aiden shudder so hard that the chains rattle against the wall. Oliver kisses and sucks on Aiden’s nipples. “Fuck,” Aiden rasps. “I want you so fucking bad.”

“You should have taken it when you had the chance,” I say.

“He wasn’t ready!”

“Yes, he was,” I argue. “Plus, Oliver likes it when you just take it from him.”

“Hell yes, he does,” Toby pants. “His pretty cock starts leaking and throbbing.”

I pull my fingers from Toby and kiss his neck. Stepping to the side, I grab the cage on Aiden’s cock and pull lightly. “He likes it, too. You love it when I chase you and fuck you so hard that you cry. Don’t you, Bitch boy?”

“Yes,” Aiden moans, jerking against his binds. I grab the key from the shelf and unlock the cage. When blood starts rapidly filling his cock, Aiden whimpers in pain, but he loves it. Just like Toby does. Oliver’s hand closes around his cock, stroking, and Aiden’s body jerks again. “Oliver. Fuck!”

“Stroke him harder,” I order. “Tighten your hand.”

Oliver’s hand gets tighter, and Aiden’s mouth drops open in pleasure. “Get him untied,” Toby says, gently pulling from Oli. We work together to get the restraints loose, and Oli doesn’t waste a second bending over and sucking Aiden into his mouth. “Holy shit, Baby.”

“Don’t hold back,” I tell Aiden, and he slides his hand into Oliver’s hair, tightening his fist.

Oliver drops to his knees, braces his hands on Aiden’s thighs, and Aiden starts fucking his mouth. “Fuck, I missed your mouth.”

I let Aiden thrust a few times before pulling Oliver away. “You’re holding back.” I gently run my fingers through his hair, and he leans back against my thigh. Aiden goes to step forward but stops when I give him a look.

“I thought Aiden was in charge,” Oliver comments, making Toby laugh.

“He was that night,” I correct. “But not all the time.” I tilt my head to the side, studying Aiden while running my fingers through Oliver’s hair. “Why were you really holding back with Oli?”

“I told you. He wasn’t ready.”

“Lie. Try again.” I reach down and help Oliver to his feet. “Go bend over the end of the bed, Cum drop.” Without a word, Oliver does as I say, and I nod for Toby to follow him. I grab Aiden’s arm and jerk him to turn around to face them.

Toby pushes Oliver to climb onto the bed on his hands and knees, lubes his cock up, and slides inside him. Aiden and I have a perfect view of every inch of Toby’s delicious pierced cock disappearing. When Toby’s fully seated, he grabs Oliver by the biceps, pulls his arms behind him and starts fucking him hard.

“Toby,” Oliver groans, and Aiden’s cock jumps.

I start circling Aiden, and his eyes are flashing between Oliver and me. “Why are you holding back?”

“I told you–”

I slap the top of his cock in warning. “Don’t fucking lie to me.”

“Oliver wanted to wait.”

I shove Aiden toward the side of the bed and push between his shoulder blades until his chest is on the bed. “Tell me the truth,” I demand. Aiden turns his head to look at Oliver, refusing to answer. “Have it your way.” I reach into the table beside the bed and pull out a bigger plug. Toby tosses me the lube, and I squirt it onto the plug, making sure it’s slick. I jerk the one inside Aiden out and start working the bigger one in. He squirms on the bed but locks his muscles so he doesn’t try to pull away from me. I get the top half in and stop when the bulb on the base expands, giving him a chance to talk. When he doesn’t, I shove it in without warning, watching him stretch around it. Aiden goes to cry out but bites his lip to stop the sound. “It’s been a long time since we’ve been in this situation, Bitch boy. Did you miss being a helpless little slut?” I push harder on the plug, and Aiden’s hands ball into fists. I lean down until my mouth is right beside his ear. “Do you have anything to say?”

“I already told you.”

---