Page 11 of Game Night: Truth or Dare

“You want me to say it again? Fuck me.”

It worked like magic. Riled and rattled him. He put the condom on, rolling it from his tip all the way down. It looked like it was suffocating his cock with the way the latex clung to it. And while he’d been fast putting the condom on, he was slow putting his cock to use.

More lube just before he pressed the tip of his cock against my ass. It hadn’t been that long since I’d been with someone, but it was the first time I’d been with someone as thick as Alex, and he made my ass know all about it.

Just the tip. My mouth opened wide, and a little squeak came out as I pressed my face into the pillow. “Fuck,” I let out.

Chapter Four

Alex

This was the tightest hole I’d ever tried to fuck in my entire life, even a tight fist around my cock hadn’t compared to the tightness of Leo. The lube made it easier, but I also didn’t want to ram right inside him and rip him in two, because that’s just how it felt pushing the tip of my cock inside him.

Going in slowly, listening to each one of his moans, I was using it as a guide of how much pressure to apply and when he was ready to go deeper. Although I didn’t know if he’d manage to take it all.

“Uh—uh—” he whimpered; hands outstretched to the metal frame above him.

I tested him and continued to push, feeling his ass envelope around my cock. I’d never been this slow with anything before. I pulled out and watched as his wide hole slowly shrunk but not before I pushed my cock back inside. He moaned much louder this time, maybe even over the sound of the music playing.

“I wanna see your face,” I said, pulling out and flipping him on his back. I’d never done this, so it was all new, and I didn’t think we could do missionary.

Leo was prepared. He immediately hiked his legs up, holding them in place as he hugged them with his arms. “Like this?”

“Perfect.” I grabbed his ass with both hands, pulling his cheeks apart slightly and lowering my hips for my cock to dangle above his hole. With his hole trying to shrink, I continued to push my cock against the hole until the tip went inside.

His eyes grew wide as he looked up at me. His lips tight together like he was trying to hold his moans in. I took that as a challenge, pushing my cock deeper, burying it inside him until he exploded with a loud moan. His hands grabbed at the bedsheets, pinging the fitted sheet from the side of the bed until they were scrunching around us.

“I’m fine,” he said, getting red in the face.

I fucked him slowly and hopefully gently, his tight hole clenched around my cock and throbbed in beat with the throb of my cock. I leaned against his legs and body, pushing them back until our faces were together, close enough to kiss.

He was flexible, a nice surprise considering how I liked to fuck.

Our lips stuck together from a kiss. I pulled back. “Tell me how you want it.”

“Harder,” he said, his hole clenching. “Faster.” He clenched again. “I don’t know if you can go deeper.” He grinned, almost on the edge of a giggle. I felt every single movement he made in his ass to my cock.

I didn’t know how to tell him that if he kept clenching my cock like that, this might be over for both of us before it even started. On my knees, spreading out on the bed, I continued to lean over him and pushing his legs back while we fucked.

His moans almost in sync with the beat of the music thumping through the house.

We tried another position, laid beside each other, fighting back the bedsheet that wouldn’t go back. I lifted his leg with one hand to get a good entry point and then I could play with his cock while I fucked him. He tried to stop me a couple times, telling me he’d cum if I continued.

It was different to what I expected it would be, more sensitive to the touch, and in that way, it was more sensual. I’d never experienced my body tingle from the tips of my toes to my throat before. We moaned in sync, creating this almost orchestra of sounds in tune to the bump of the music against the floor and walls.

He reached behind, grabbing at me. “I’m gonna cum,” he said.

I immediately pulled out, to him letting a loud moan free followed by a sigh, probably relief. I wouldn’t know, nothing was going inside me like that.

On our backs, we laid beside each other. I pulled the condom off my cock, and he started tossing as hard and fast as he could. I mimicked his hand motion, although I was right-handed and from some of the jerk motions he made, I didn’t think he was used to using his left hand.

It was quick.

He came, shooting cum up his naked body. Seeing his eyes screw shut, his toes curl, and his body sink down the bed with pleasure, I experienced a pleasure jolt through me, sending my load up my torso.

Then came the immediate sensitivity as we both laid there, panting for breath. We turned to each other, the cum dripping sideways onto the bed.

Pressing a finger to his chest, I swiped the cum and sucked my finger clean. It had become cold on our bodies, but that didn’t impact the flavour, it was a mixture of what mine usually tasted like, just a sticky liquid, except a touch sweeter, probably a happy accident of the cream from his body.

---