Page 50 of Keeping Katie

Taking a deep breath, I nod and do my best to relax on the mattress. “I do trust you.”

He presses a kiss to my forehead. “Thank you. I’ll never abuse your trust. Ready?”

I shoot him an incredulous look that makes him chuckle before he moves behind me, opens a drawer to the bedside table, then pulls out a small bottle and something he hides in his palm.

Oh, God. He’s going to look at my butthole. And put something inside of it. I’ve never experienced anything like this before. What if I scream? Or toot? I would absolutely die of humiliation. I squeeze my eyes shut and take inventory of howmy stomach feels. Are the odds in my favor or not? That would be the worst possible thing that could happen.

“Take some breaths, baby girl. I can practically feel your panic. Trust that I’ll take care of you. Always.”

His velvety tone helps, and I let out a deep exhale. “Thank you, Daddy.”

Despite the fact that I’m nervous as hell, I’m also warm all over and hoping he can’t see how turned on I am by all of this. I’m giving myself over to him and letting him do what he wants to me. I’d wondered before if I was submissive. Based on how hot all of this makes me, the answer is pretty freaking clear.

He brings his hand to my lower back and slowly strokes down my crack. He doesn’t stop at my hole, and I’m a little relieved but also disappointed. Why am I excited about this? Is it good excitement or bad excitement? I can’t figure that out.

Then a drop of something cold hits my ass, and I jump. He keeps a hand on my lower back, steadying me. I whimper but am quickly distracted when he moves a finger over the tight ring of my hole and strokes it. Oh my God. That feels so weird. And good. And naughty.

“Daddy,” I whisper.

“You’re being such a good girl, Katie. I know you’re going to take your punishment so well because you’re always my good girl.”

My nipples bud, and my pussy clenches. I’m quickly distracted from those two things as he starts to make slow thrusts into my ass.

It burns, but there’s another sensation, too, and it’s surprising the heck out of me. I didn’t expect to feel such pleasure from this. Maybe it’s the mix of taboo and anticipation adding to it. Whatever it is, I love it.

“One day, I’m going to fuck this ass, baby.”

I shudder at the thought. His cock is huge. Probably ten times the size of his index finger, and I already feel full that.

He squirts some more lube on my ass and starts to add a second finger. I stop breathing and grip the bed, squeezing my eyes shut.

“Let your breath out. You need to relax, baby.” He pauses his movements and waits until I obey. “Good girl. Another one. Keep going.”

With each one I take, he presses in deeper, stretching me around him. The more I breathe, the better it feels. Soon, I’m moaning out loud.

“I love watching your ass swallow my fingers. I can hardly wait to see my cock sinking in there.”

I let out a whine of protest when he pulls his hand away, leaving me feeling empty.

“My baby likes her ass being played with,” he says as he touches something smooth and cold to my hole. “Don’t worry, baby. We’re not done.”

He presses gently, the toy stretching me wider and wider. I wiggle, then startle when he smacks my ass.

“Naughty girl. Stay still. This is a punishment.”

It might be a punishment, but it’s a pleasurable one so far, and I think he’s enjoying the hell out of it too. Especially considering I can see his enormous cock outlined in his pants when I look back at him.

“Deep breath in and then out.”

I do what he says. As I exhale, he presses on the toy until it pops into place. Suddenly, I’m full and hornier than ever.

“That looks so pretty, baby. I’m going to have to invest in a princess plug with real diamonds at the base. I’ll have you wear it for me with nothing else on.”

Holy espresso beans. Grady is kinky. Hell, maybe I am, too, considering I’m loving every second of this.

“Crawl up onto the bed, baby. On your hands and knees.”

When I don’t move, he smacks my ass again. “One. Don’t make me get to three, Little one, because this can go from fun to serious in a heartbeat.”

---