Page 130 of Fake Out Hearts

She rises up to meet me, and I give the kiss everything I have. I need her to know that she’s safe with me, that she always will be. I’d never do anything to hurt her.

“If it hurts at all, just tell me and I’ll stop, okay?” I say when we part. “We don’t have to go any further than you’re comfortable with.”

She nods and her tense body relaxes underneath me. “Okay.”

“You’re such a good girl,” I praise as I start to smear the lube across her hole with my thumb. Then I start to apply pressure, gently pressing into her until my first knuckle slips inside. She gasps and her eyes widen.

“Are you okay?” I murmur.

“Oh my god,yes,” she breathes. Her forehead falls onto the bed as I work my thumb in and out of her, opening her up. Tiny shudders wrack her body as she whimpers, “That feels amazing.”

“Is it okay if I add another finger?”

She nods again. I pull out my thumb and press into her with my index and middle fingers, aware of the way her breath catches as she adjusts to the intrusion.

“Good girl, you’re doing so fucking well. Take a deep breath. I’ve got you. I’ll make sure it feels good.”

Her chest rises and falls as she takes a series of breaths, relaxing into it and allowing my fingers to slide into her with ease. She moans softly as I start to fuck her gently with those two fingers.

“There you go. Perfect. Work your clit too, it’ll help you open up,” I instruct.

She reaches between her legs obediently, biting her lower lip. As soon as her hand finds her clit, she squirms back against me, giving me deeper access. She starts to lose herself in it, and I can feel every response in her body as I get her ready for me.

“Just like that.” I nod, my heart pounding. “Fuck, this is so hot. I can’t wait to feel you around my cock.”

“I want that too,” she gasps. “I want you to fuck me like this.”

Blood rushes to my cock at her words, and I groan as I draw my fingers out of her slowly.

“I can’t fucking wait, baby. It’s going to feel so amazing. God, you’re beautiful like this.”

“Please. Fuck me now. I can’t wait either, Theo, oh god…”

Her voice is raspy, and her free hand clenches the sheets as I pull my fingers out entirely and settle on my knees behind her.

“You’re ready for me, princess? You want to feel me fuck your ass?”

“Yes,” she whispers hungrily.

I reach for the bottle of lube lying on the bed beside us and coat my cock in slickness, then line my head up to her tight back hole.

“Take a deep breath,” I murmur.

She does, her eyelashes fluttering as her lips part slightly. As she releases the breath, I shift my hips forward, pressing inside her.

“Oh god,” she whimpers.

I drag a hand down the curve of her spine. “So good, baby. You’re taking me so well. Such a good fucking girl for me.”

“Yes. Yes. Oh fuck. More.”

She takes another breath, and I wait for her to release it, then roll my hips forward until another inch or so of my cock is buried inside her. I’m amazed she’s able to open like this for me, because I know how big I am, but she’s taking it so well.

“That’s my good girl. Open up for me,” I encourage her as I palm her ass.

“Fuck me, Theo,” she begs, and her words hit me right in the chest. “I need it. I need you.”

Hanging on to my restraint by a thread, I slowly push the rest of the way in. I want to make this incredible for her, so I’m more focused on her pleasure than on mine—which is probablythe only reason I haven’t come already, because she feels fucking amazing.

---