Page 25 of The Rule of 3

Eli opened the cabinet and cocked his head to the side, asking, “Why do you have two different sizes in here? And why do you even need them? Aren’t you on birth control, Zoë?”

“I am, Eli. We use those for… special things,” she blushed.

Tanner spoke up, “It seems our naughty teacher here is very fond of anal play. We decided it was a good idea to use condoms for that. You know… hygiene and all?”

Eli raised his eyebrows at her and said, “My, my. Youarethe woman of my dreams, Zoë. But why two sizes?”

“Reach behind that bottle of lube,” Tanner directed.

Eli complied and pulled out a box of… sex toys. Looking at Zoë with even greater appreciation, he exclaimed, “Ohh… so you like a little mechanical excitement, do you? Well, this is very promising.” He rummaged around, randomly pulling out butt plugs, vibrators in a couple of different styles and sizes, a cock ring, and a few things he didn’t even understand. “So, you use a condom on this skinny dildo for some backdoor fun? Who gets it in the ass, may I ask?”

In a small voice, Zoë answered, “It’s always been me so far, but I’ve wanted to use it on Tanner too.”

Tanner coughed and smiled. “You should have spoken up!” Then he turned his attention back to Eli. “I think for now, we’ll stick to the basics. Grab one of the larger condoms and suit up… or not. It’s up to Zoë.”

Looking serious for a moment, Zoë seemed to consider things. “Look, I know you’ve only been with Tanner for a long, long time, but Tanner’s sister just got pregnant while she was on the pill. It would be one thing for me to have that happen with Tanner, but I’m not sure I’m ready for that with you, Eli, as remote a possibility as it is. So, let’s have you use a condom for now, alright?”

Eli smiled and nodded. “It’s fine, Zoë. I completely understand. And if that changes, you’ll be my first.” He gave her a wink.

“Okay,” Tanner said encouragingly, “I want to watch you fuck Zoë, Eli. Let’s do this!” He rubbed his hands together, chuckling. “This is like my dirtiest fantasy coming to life.”

A shiver went through Eli as he tore the package open. He rolled on the condom and lay down on the bed, drawing Zoë down next to him.

Sitting up, Zoë asked sweetly, “Kiss him some more, Tanner, please?” Tanner didn’t wait. He lay down beside his friend and brought their mouths together. Immediately, Tanner’s hand went for Eli’s junk and started to play. Zoë was so turned on she started pulling at her nipples. “God, you guys! You look amazing doing that.” She scooched close to Eli and began to caress his body—tentatively at first, then gradually with more confidence. He snaked his arm around her and pulled her on top of him.

Zoë got the picture immediately, so she straddled Eli and let her body sink down onto his erection. The men broke their kiss as Eli hissed and moaned.

Tanner pulled back for a better view. His eyes dilated as he saw his wife impale herself on his best friend’s dick as she sighed with pleasure. “Oh my god,” he moaned in a strangled voice. “This is so wrong and one hundred percent right at the same time.” Tanner reached between Zoë’s legs and began to stroke her clit.

Zoë slid up and down on Eli as Eli kept his eyes glued to the action. His moans grew louder and louder, watching Tanner’s hand and her pussy gliding up and down.

Tanner scooted into position so that he could use two hands then. Zoe was so turned on and wet, he had no trouble sliding one of his fingers inside of her alongside Eli’s shaft. Zoë almost collapsed with desire as she felt the extra stretch and knew that Tanner was caressing both Eli and her at the same time. “Oh, Tanner! You can feel us both, can’t you?” she cried. “That is so fucking hot!” Tanner’s finger on her clit pushed harder, and she sped up her pumping up and down, clenching her inner muscles on Tanner’s hand and Eli’s dick, crying, “Yes! Ohh!” as yet another climax rolled through her.

Eli’s hips began to thrust upwards over and over, and his eyes slammed shut as if he couldn’t handle it anymore. He quickly flipped Zoë over so he was now the one on top. Tanner’s hand slipped out of Zoë but he remained next to them, his body plastered to Zoë’s and Eli’s sides. Tanner stroked Eli’s butt with one hand while the other petted and plucked at Zoë’s nipple. “Fuck her, Eli! Make Zoë feel you!” His eyes alternated between assessing Zoë’s pleasure by the look on her face to the sight of their beautiful bodies joined together. He was getting hard all over again and rubbed his erection against Eli’s leg as Eli pumped into Zoë.

Eli pounded harder and faster into Zoë. She moaned and panted with each deep thrust. And finally, he roared with his release. Over and over, he thrust into her, feeling Tanner’s firm grip on his ass—until it seemed there was nothing left of him.

Eli collapsed onto Zoë’s other side. They all three lay there in post-rapture, stunned silence until Eli asked, “Jesus, did that really just happen?” This brought another purr and a couple of giggles out of Zoë.

“Hmm…” Tanner mused. “You’re taking your best man duties pretty seriously, Eli.” He laughed with them.

“Just wait until I’m your chief of staff,” he responded cockily. Then he grew serious and added, “You both know… this changes everything, right?” He leaned across Zoë to kiss Tanner, and then he moved his mouth to Zoë’s. When he’d sufficiently kissed her brains out too, he pulled back and declared, “Now you’re both mine… and I’m yours.”

“Holy decadence!” breathed Zoë. “We’re a throuple!”

After ditching the condom and some general cleanup, they all flopped back onto the bed and slept for three hours.

Chapter 23

Zoë awoke when a loud grumbling noise startled her. It sounded really close. As she drifted out of her exhausted slumber fog, she became aware that her head was planted on Eli’s belly, and his stomach was growling. So, it was finally hunger that drove them all from their cozy tangle of arms and legs.

She sat up and stretched, taking in the glorious sight of her two men. Their legs were intertwined, and they blinked sleepily at her and at each other.

“I feel like I could eat a horse,” Tanner announced. He grabbed his flannel pants and wandered into the kitchen. Two minutes later, he was back, saying, “I just turned on a pot of coffee and put the breakfast casserole in the oven that my assistant made and brought by yesterday. She knew we’d be worn out today, so that was nice of her.” Smiling, he eyed Eli and Zoë, who looked like two satisfied cats curled up in the big bed. “It’ll be ready soon.”

After a huge breakfast, Eli got a serious look on his face and said, “Zoë, I need to head over to have a chat with your parents. I think they’re planning to go back to the west coast, and I’d frankly prefer to see that happen sooner rather than later. I’m sorry, and I don’t want to hurt your feelings in any way, but we need to think of appearances for Tanner’s campaign and they don’t… um… exactly…” his voice trailed off and he looked at the ceiling with a sigh.

“I get it, Eli. They’re embarrassing to me too. Imagine growing up in that house with them.” She shook her head. “But I’d like to go over there with you so I can at least spend a little time with them before they leave again. I’ve barely seen them in years. I feel sort of obligated to play the part of the good daughter, you know?”

---