Page 57 of The Dom with the Clever Tongue

“Hm. That’s too bad, because if your Domme says it’s okay I’m going to do it anyway. Not today, but soon.” He pulled his fingers from her pussy and brushed a finger against her other hole.

“Nooo!” She went up on her toes and tried to squirm away, but Malachi grabbed her thigh to keep her still and did it again. She squealed and tried to close her legs enough to protect herself, but he wedged his knees between her legs so she couldn’t draw them together.

His free hand shifted to the small of her back, pinning her to the table. Scarlet teased her clit while Malachi got her used to having her bottom played with.

When she was finally quiet, accepting it, Malachi grabbed the lube and squeezed some onto his finger. He spread it around, then pressed his finger against her virgin entrance. “Relax, princess. This will go easier if you don’t fight it. I’m going to hurt you later, but not like this.”

Scarlet hissed, then whimpered and held very still.

“That’s a good girl. That’s not so bad, is it?” He slid his finger in to the first knuckle then out a little, then pressed it in further. When it was all the way in he winked at Scarlet, then turned his gaze back to what he was doing. “See? That wasn’t so bad now, was it?” Slowly, he finger-fucked her ass, crooning to her about how good she was to let him do it.

Scarlet moved around the table so she could see Reece’s face. There were tears on her cheeks and she looked both uncomfortable and turned on, but not upset.

“You okay, baby?”

“It feels weird,” she sniffled.

“And good?”

Reece’s eyes shut tight and she gasped. “I don’t know. Yes. Fuck.”

“Who were you saving your ass for, Reece?” Malachi asked, his voice deeper than usual.

“For you, Sir.”

He chuckled. “I’ll allow you to lie about that. Nothing else though. Has anyone else touched you here before?”

“Scarlet, Sir.”

“You’ve done this to her before, Scarlet?”

“No. I’ve slid a finger across it a couple of times, when I was going down on her but she said no, so I stopped.”

“You’re the Domme now. You get to do what you want unless she safewords. Capiche?”

She nodded to him. He grabbed the plug and handed it to Scarlet. “Put more lube on this. You’re putting it in her ass.”

Blood singing in her ears, Scarlet did as he’d instructed. He pulled her between his legs, so she was tucked between him and Reece. She felt the hardness of his erection pressed against her backside. Just when she’d thought she couldn’t get any more turned on, more heat flared through her. Being between them like this made Scarlet play through several scenarios in her head. The possibilities could keep them busy for ages.

Slowly, Malachi slid his finger out of Reece. Scarlet placed the plug against her girlfriend’s tiny hole.

“Ugh. Cold!” Reece wriggled, but didn’t try to get away.

“Are you sure this is going to fit?”

Malachi chuckled. “It’s not much thicker than my finger, see? Just don’t rush.”

Scarlet pressed on it, and Reece gasped.

“It’s too big!” she whined.

“If you think that’s big, wait until it’s my cock, baby girl. You should be glad you have such a nice Domme. She could have bought a much bigger one and expected you to take it for her,” he admonished. “Try to push it out with your body, it’ll go in easier.”

Reece’s muscles twitched and jumped. Scarlet was patient, stroking her free hand over her girl’s ass until she calmed. She toyed with the plug and pressed, and eventually it inched into her and slid into place. The girl let out a low, tortured moan and Scarlet swallowed hard and tried to slow her racing pulse. She traced around the gem with her fingertip and Reece trembled.

“Good girl. I can’t believe how still you stayed for me.” Scarlet stroked a hand over Reece’s lower back and bottom then patted her on the plug.

The girl squeaked and shuddered from head to toe. Malachi went to wash the lube off his hands.

---