Page 16 of The Nice List

“Just like that, baby. Look at you, taking my cock in that pretty little mouth,” I tell her as I reach down to run my thumbs along her stretched jaw. “Oh, fuck, that feels good,” I say when she hums at my praise.

She works me faster now that she’s loosened up enough to let me slip into her throat with every bob of her head, and I know I’m not going to last much longer.

“I’m right there, baby,” I warn her.

When she hums and swallows, her throat flexes around the head of my dick, setting me off. I grip the back of her head as I start to pump into her throat. She pulls back just enough that the next few ropes pump into her mouth and she moans at the flavor as she swallows around me until I’m completely spent.

I pull her up until she’s straddling my lap and kiss her deeply, tasting myself on her mouth. “You’re fucking perfect, Livvy. I can’t wait to take the rest of your firsts.”

“I’m ready when you are.” She wiggles her hips over my sensitive dick.

I give her a light smack on the ass. “Be still, baby. If you wake that monster back up, I’m going to fuck you into next week. I’d rather save that for next time.”

Her brows pull together in confusion. “Next time?”

I nod. “You know I’m not a nice guy in general, but I told you I want to do this right.”

“Oh. If you don’t want to…”

“Stop!” I say, cutting her off. “I want you—all of you—and Iwillhave you when the time is right.” I lean forward to kiss her lips softly. “I want to have you inmybed.” I kiss her cheek. “I want to take my time with you.” I kiss her forehead before pulling back to look at her. “I’m all yours…and you are mine. Understand?”

She gives me that smile that I think I just might kill for. “Yes, Sir.”

“Good girl.” I flip us so that she’s lying beneath me, making her giggle before I stretch out beside her with my arm tucked under her head.

As she snuggles up next to me with her head on my chest, I realize how complete I feel. I don’t remember ever being this content to just lay with a woman before Livvy. I guess she’s getting some of my firsts, too. I wasn’t lying when I said I’m not a nice guy. But for her…I will be.

Livvy

I wake up with a tingling in my lower stomach. It’s not unusual for me to wake in the middle of the night needing to pee, but this doesn’t feel like that. This feels like… “Ooohhh,” I moan as my consciousness catches up to my body.

I look down my body to meet Cory’s eyes as he licks my pussy. The sight mixed with the feeling of what he’s doing while I’m still in my hazy state has me teetering on the edge of an orgasm that feels like it’s going to tear me apart.

Cory lifts his head just long enough to say, “Finally. Give it to me, baby.” Then, he sucks my clit into his mouth, biting it gently as his thumb teases my entrance and I come with a shout.

I feel the gush just before Cory groans and lowers his mouth to suck my lips where they’re dripping with the most intense orgasm I’ve ever had. My body feels like it’s being powered by thousands of electrical wires as he kisses his way up my body.

He licks my lips and I eagerly suck his tongue into my mouth just as his hard cock brushes against my sensitive clit. He lets out a sinister laugh when I whine as he pulls back. “I told you what would happen if you woke that monster up.” He thrusts his hips, rubbing his dick through my wet lips.

“Finally. Give it to me,” I throw his own words back at him as I wiggle beneath him.

As intense as the orgasm was, I needed more. I was asleep during the buildup. I didn’t get to enjoy it like I had all the times before. Somehow, that makes me feel cheated. Desperate. Floating somewhere between bliss and torture.

“Please,” I whine petulantly when he shakes his head.

“I don’t want to hurt you, Liv. There’s no way I could be gentle right now. I didn’t know edging you in your sleep would get me so worked up.” He thrusts his hips again without entering me and we both groan at the sensation.

“Me either,” I admit. “It wasn’t on my list before and it never will be if you leave me like this.” I drop my hand to wrap it around him, stroking before trying to position him at my entrance.

When he shifts his weight to the side, I grip him tighter, afraid he’s going to stop me. “Fuck, baby. Don’t stop. That feels fuckingamazing,” he says as his finger replaces the head of his cock at my entrance.

“Aahhh.” I wince as his finger enters me suddenly. I shake my head when he looks at me with concern. “I’m fine. Please don’t stop,” I beg, moving my hips in encouragement.

He pumps his dick into my fist, the head rubbing my clit each time, as his finger enters me again and again until I’m trembling with another orgasm.

“That’s it, baby. I’m going to come with you and mark this pretty pussy with my cum.” He curls his finger inside me, peaking my release just as I feel the hot splash of his cum cover both of our hands.

“This is getting ridiculous.” I giggle once I catch my breath enough to speak.

---