Page 19 of The Nice List

“Not what, baby?” I slide my thumb into her pussy as I push my middle finger into her ass to the second knuckle.

“Not your finger.” She moves her hips to ride my fingers, back and forth, working both holes. “I want your cock inside me when I come. I need it.”

I clinch my hand, making her wince. “Fuck, Livvy. You want me to fuck you in the ass before I’ve even fucked this pretty pussy?”

“Ohhh,” she moans. “I’d rather you fuck my pussy, but I know you won’t.”

“I won’t fuck your ass either,” I tell her. “But I’ll come down your pretty throat while you ride me just like this.” I push my middle finger all the way into her ass until I can feel the tip of my thumb in her pussy.

“Yes! Hurry. I’m…Oh, God…” She moans again as I spin around to straddle her face. She takes me in her mouth before I’m even situated and sucks violently.

I keep the rhythm of my finger and thumb as I gently thrust my cock into her mouth. The idea that I have all of her holes filled almost makes me come on the spot, but there’s no way I’ll let that happen before tasting her. I drop my head to suck her clit into my mouth, setting her off instantly as my cock slides further into her throat.

She swallows around me as she undulates her hips again, and I’m gone.

We both come violently—me with a roar and her with a convulsing tremor that floods my mouth with her sweetness.

Livvy

I smile as I see the dotted line of bruises on my arms and legs.Who knew Christmas lights could be so much fun?

“Fuck, that’s hot!” Cory says as he steps into the shower behind me.

“The water?” I giggle as I spin around to face him. “Or the roadmap you made of my skin?”

“Yes.” He chuckles before bending to kiss me. “I shouldn’t be proud of the marks…but I am.”

“Me, too,” I admit. “Maybe I should wear tank tops around the dorm room until Alexis drills me about them. Then, I’d be forced to fess up about us.”

“Don’t do that.” Cory lets out a huff. “You’ll tell her when you’re ready for this to be real.”

“Thisisreal,” I argue. “I don’t know why it’s so hard for me to just tell her. It’s not like you two were ever serious. I’m not betraying her by being with you. I just know that she won’t like me being with anyone. Especially someone ten years older with a bad boy reputation.”

“You don’t want to disappoint her.” Cory guesses the root of my issue. “I get it. That’s why I left it up to you, baby. I don’t want to force you into joining my bad reputation.”

“I’m not worried about my reputation, Cory.” I lift my hand to run my fingers through his wet hair and smile when he dips his head to give me better access. “I love you.”

“I know,pretty girl.” His hands come up to hold my head. “I love you, too.”

We finish in the shower and climb into his bed to snuggle the rest of the night.

Alexis is leaving when classes end next week to spend Winter Break with Maddox. So, I’ll have three weeks with no big sister supervision. I’ll drive to my parent’s house on Christmas Eve and then come back to Thorngrove the day after Christmas. I plan to spend the rest of my time glued to Cory. Maybe I’ll find a way to tell her about my relationship by the time she returns for the New Year’s Eve party.

Chapter 13

Cory

“How’s it going with your girl?” My sister takes the last bite of her third helping of mashed potatoes and gravy.

That’s the benefit of Christmas dinner for two. We don’t have to worry about leaving anything for the other guests…because there aren’t any.

“Fine,” I say nonchalantly as I reach for my beer to wash down the turkey. “How’s it going with you and Slade?”

“Fine.” She shrugs, trying to look as unaffected as I am.

We have a two second stare down before we both laugh.

“Oh, little bro.” Maxine wipes a thumb under her eye. “How do we get ourselves into these situationships?”

---