Page 62 of Pirate

Pirate wasn’tsure which one of them was more surprised by Sophia’s second orgasm. He honestly hadn’t expected her to come the first time he played with her ass. But damn, once he got his finger inside and started to pump the single digit in and out of her rear, it was like he’d hooked her up to a twelve volt battery. She writhed and begged for more. Careful to not put the finger that had just been inside her ass back into pussy, Pirate dipped his ring and middle fingers inside to get them lubed up by her juices.

Then he worked his pointer finger back inside her ass. After only two pumps, he added his middle finger too. Sophia shook over him, completely forgetting her task of sucking him off. Which was probably a good thing, because he was near bursting without her even touching his cock. It was so fucking hot to see his fingers going in and out of her tight, little ass.

Fuck, he’d been such a dumbass. How could he have not realized all this time, the reason sex was different with Sophia was because he was falling in love with her?

When she seemed ready, he worked his ring finger in too.

Using her pussy juices and his saliva wasn’t ideal. What he really needed was the damn lube bottle that was in his nightstand.

Following her second orgasm, Sophia toppled boneless on top of him. Her body fell forward some, with her ass landing just below his chin. Removing his fingers from her tight hole, he gave her a single, sharp swat across both cheeks.

Sophia jumped. “What the hell?”

“I just realized something.” He brought his hand down on her right cheek, squeezing the flesh. “I told you that I loved you.” His left palm landed on her left cheek. She moaned. “But you never said it back.”

“I did!” she insisted. Despite the whine in her voice, she raised herself up onto her knees to lift her ass more.

“You didn’t!” Her body jolted at his harsh swat. Her ass reddened so beautifully. “Tell me now!”

“No!” Sophia cried out.

“Do you want to get spanked, naughty girl?” Pirate demanded, bring both hands down together that time.

Sophia gasped out. It sounded so pitiful, but then she moaned. He had the perfect view of her ass and pussy from his angle. She was soaked with arousal. Her pussy lips were swollen and red from his ministrations. Fuck, just when he thought shecouldn’t look any sexier, he noticed his beard burn on the inside of her thighs coated moist with her juices. Now there was a sight.

He swatted her ass again. “Tell me you love me. I’ll keep going until you do.”

“I already told you!” she insisted.

“Then tell me again!” he demanded, bringing his palm across her ass crack.

Sophia stubbornly cried out, “No!” again.

One, two, three sharp strikes in a row. Sophia’s cry echoed off of the walls. “God, Pirate!”

“Tell,”slap, “me,”slap, “what,”slap, “I want,”slap, “to hear!”Slap! Slap!

Her ass was a fiery red. He squeezed the globes to add to the sensation. He would need to give her a bath later to help cool her off.

“Stop!” she cried.

Pirate immediately lowered his hands. For a moment, he wondered if he’d gone too far, but she was the one in control. Game or not, she could have called a halt at any time.

Gasping over top of him, Sophia got herself up onto her arms. She twisted around to face him. He was shocked to see tears running down her cheeks.

“Fuck, Sophia! I’m so sorry—” He reached up to wipe at her tears, but she caught his hands before he could touch her face.

Bending down, she pressed her lips to his fingertips. Then she pressed a kiss to his right palm. Cradling his hand to her cheek, her bright hazel eyes captivated his own.

“I love you.”

Pirate’s breath caught. Torn between worry that he’d gone too far and caused her real pain and the elation of hearing those words cross her lips for the first time, there was a solid minute where his heart may have stopped beating.

She leaned down and claimed his mouth. Still clutching his hand to her, they spent a long time just tasting each other and tasting themselves on the other’s lips and tongue.

When they pulled away to catch their breath, Pirate saw her tears had mostly been wiped away. He removed the rest with his thumbs. “You mean it, right? I didn’t push you into saying it before you were ready?”

She nodded between his hands. “I mean it.”

---