Page 60 of The Penalty

He laughs. “Because you have no volume control. These walls are thin, and my mother is awake.”

“Now you’re the worst.”

Rhys shoves a hand between us and cups me through my pants. I bite my lip and whimper to try to keep the sound down but he’s right, I’m so loud.

“You’re trying so hard, aren’t you?” He rubs his palm down my shaft and back up. I grip his arms just to have something to hold on to and gasp as my body trembles. “Stay quiet and I’ll keep going.”

“Rhys,” I say his name in a whine and plea.

“Shh.”

“I need—” I start to say ‘you’ but freeze. “To come.”

“I know.” He shoves down my pants and wraps his hand around me. “Fuck, you’re big. I have to say, I might love your cock.”

“Fucking taste it then!”

Rhys’ free hand slaps over my mouth. “Shh!” The hand wrapped around me stops moving and I damn near sob. “What did I say?”

“No, please. Keep going. I’m sorry.” I lean my face into his neck and cover my mouth with his skin. It’s so hard not to suck on it. Not to leave a mark. But I know he’d have questions if he did, and I don’t want to make this harder for him.

But he doesn’t stroke me again. I could scream.

“Are you going back to your parents tonight?”

He wants to chit chat?!

“No,” I groan, rolling my hips to try to get him to move. “Dorms. Game tomorrow.”

“You better get going then, it’s late.” He releases me and puts his hands on my shoulders. This time I do yell but I keep my lips against his neck to muffle the sound.

“I hate you.”

“Consider it payback for blocking me.”

“You’re so mean.”

“Remember that next time.”

Rhys grabs my jaw and ravages my mouth. It’s over too fast and I’m still left aching, but I manage to get myself put away so I can leave without flashing his mom.

I’m so damn cold when I get back to the dorms. I’m pretty sure my dick has crawled back inside of my body.

I’m curled up on my bed with every blanket I own trying to get blood circulating in my body when my phone goes off.

Not My Brother: Did you make it back? The rats didn’t get you?

That reminds me he needs a different nickname. He’s definitely not my brother but…

Teddy changed Rhys’ contact to Loves My Cock.

Cherry Pumpkin: no thanks to u

Loves My Cock: Maybe they were scared away by the size of your erection. You’re welcome.

Cherry Pumpkin: no way they arent scared of dicks. plus it was so cold it almost froze off!

Rhys changed Teddy’s contact to Fake Boyfriend

---