Page 19 of Extra Tight

“It’s your choice, Goldie. I can put another finger inside you and pop your cherry right now. You’ve cum all over the place, so your pussy is nice and soft.” I lean forward and take a taste of her cunt. I can’t get enough. “Or I can do it with my cock.” I know which I’d prefer, but I’ll let her decide. “What’s it going to be?”

I lazily lick her clit as she begins to writhe. She’s close to another orgasm, and I’m keeping her at the edge.

“You have to say the words, baby girl.”

“You.” The word is clipped, and I grin against her pussy.

“My fingers or my cock?” She huffs like she doesn’t want to say it, but I’m not letting her hide.

“Your cock.” We lock eyes, and I take one long lick between her pussy lips.

“Good girl.” I can feel her cunt clench around my finger when I call her that.

In one movement, I stand up and push her to the center of the bed. When I climb on top of her, her eyes are wide with fear.

“Hey,” I say gently as I push her thighs open. “It’s me. I’m not going to hurt you. Just the tip, okay?”

“Okay,” she says softly.

I grab the base of my cock and point it to her wet hole. I know for a fact she’s not on birth control, but I don’t say anything. I’m not using a fucking condom, so what’s the point in bringing it up? I want to cum in her raw and see what happens. Maybe I get her pregnant, maybe I don’t. But the thought of playing that dangerous game has me leaking with excitement. Who knows, maybe I’ll breed her into being mine forever.

When I press my cock against her, I feel the tight barrier of her cunt stop me. She whimpers and then puts her hands over her face.

“That’s it, just breathe,” I tell her as she grips the head of my cock to where it’s almost painful. My face scrunches as I breathe through it and manage to get the tip in. Once it’s there, I feel her body relax. “There you go, baby girl. I’ve got you.”

I lie down on top of her, letting the weight of my body hold her in place. Then I grab her wrists and hold her to the bed so she can’t wiggle away from me.

“Fuck.” I grunt as I push in a little more, and Goldie cries out. “Be a good girl, let me in.”

“It’s too much.” She tries to shove against me, but it’s no use. I’m too heavy, and my cock is already in place.

“You can take it. You love me, don’t you, Goldie?” I pull out just a tiny bit and then pop the tip back in. These shallow thrusts are killing me, but it feels like her pussy is sucking the cum right out of my dick.

“You know I do,” she whispers, but she’s still trying to fight me.

“Then show me you love me. Let me in.”

There’s a fire in her eyes as she fights harder. “It’s too big,” she practically shouts in my face, but I ignore it.

“Goddamn, I’m gonna cum.” My eyes roll to the back of my head as I push in a little more. “You’re doing it, baby girl. You’ve got my cock inside you. Just like I always wanted.”

“Nash.” She gets wetter and stops fighting me.

“Kiss me,” I tell her. “Kiss me like you mean it. Like you want me to be yours.”

Chapter Thirteen

GOLDIE

My mouth meets Nash’s, and I try desperately to pour everything into the kiss. His entire body covers mine inside and outside, and I want to show him how much I love him. There’s no way I could ever say the words out loud, but I feel it.

If I did, he might realize this means so much more to me than just needing his help. I want him to see me as more than the annoying little girl that was pushed into his life. Not some obligation he has to tend to.

Nash groans as more of his weight comes down on me. I let out a small gasp when his cock slides in deeper, and then there’s a warmth filling my body. There’s a sharp pain at the same time, and my teeth sink into his bottom lip. When I taste blood, I let go, and I’m shocked to realize what I’ve done.

“I’m sorry,” I rush to say.

Nash's eyes remain closed, his expression one of agony. I kiss his bottom lip in apology because I didn’t mean to hurt him. He’s trying to help me, and I go and bite him! Maybe I’m a brat after all.

---