“Ooh!” Her anus squeezed in response to the sudden sensation.
“Have you taken anyone back here before?” I rubbed my thumb over her back entrance, massaging the lube in. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to know the answer.
“No.”
Thank fuck. Yes, it was wrong of me to be so possessive of this part of her, to take something that belonged to only me, but I was a fucking wolf.
To a human, I was alpha to the core.
I applied a little pressure, breaching her hole and stretching it to take my thumb. Slowly, carefully, I worked. “Are you nervous?”
A shiver went through her. “A little.”
“I’m gonna take good care of you, honey. I’ll make it good. Do you trust me?” I withdrew my thumb and massaged her ass, squeezing and rubbing it. Felt the heat of those lush globes against my palms.
“Yes.”
“Good girl.” I untied her wrists and leaned over to kiss her mouth, plunging my tongue in deep.
She moaned against my lips.
I rearranged her hips back down on the pillows because being lower was an easier position for anal. The flesh wasn’t stretched too tight the way it would be if I’d left her on her knees, and I wanted this first time to be as easy on her as possible.
“Put your fingers between your legs, honey. I want you to touch yourself while I’m fucking your ass.”
Joy complied, lifting her hips to slide her hand underneath her as I lubed my cock up. Watching her was a sight. Another time, I’d sit in my reading chair and watch her touch herself and make herself come in our bed.
I spread her cheeks to get at her back entrance. I nudged her with the head of my cock.
Instinctively, she tightened.
I waited. “Relax, honey,” I murmured. “This is gonna feel good.”
Her right rosebud softened as she exhaled.
“Take a deep breath and then push back at me.”
She obeyed, and I gained entrance with a silent pop.
“Oh!” she called out. At first, I stilled, letting her adjust. It was so fucking tight already, I could come just like this.
When her body relaxed even more, I went slowly, letting the tight ring of muscles slide open without me insisting. Without creating any tension or resistance. “That’s it, honey. A little further, and we’ll be past the head, and then you’re going to love the way it feels.”
She braced, so I stilled.
Sweat dotted my brow, and I intentionally kept my fingers relaxed on her hips. “You control it, baby. Push back when you’re ready.”
She did just that, and the thickest part of my cock slipped all the way in.
Holy fucking shit. “Feel good?” I asked through gritted teeth.
She moaned. I heard the slick of her fingers playing with her pussy.
“Good girl. You keep working that juicy pussy of yours while I work your ass,” I told her.
“Y–es, sir.”
Fuck, she was cute. Even though I’d already marked her as mine, I wanted to devour her. Consume her. She was incredible.