Page 35 of Contrition

I was no stranger to the size of my brother. And while that would generally be the weirdest thing someone could ever say—we lived together, and we experienced tour life together, too. I had somehow seen that man’s dick more times than I had seen random girls’ tits in a crowd.

Which was…a lot.

It was how I knew that her gulp absolutely wasn’t faked.

“You gonna make it,mi Estrella?” I groaned out as my fist tightened on my length. “You gonna take that big cock while I watch?”

“I-I think he may be bigger than you. And that’s…fucking terrifying. How am I supposed to take you?”

Precum dripped from my dick at her words, and as I watched Theo grab Estrella by the ankles and drag her to the edge of the bed, I was surprised that I didn’t bust right then and there again.

“Move your panties to the side. I’ll show you exactly how you can take me.” One of his hands spread her legs while the other gripped at her waist. “C’mon now. You heard Zack. And you want to see how long I can last, yeah? Be a good girl.”

I moved my hand faster. Fuck, how I wanted to blow just so I could interrupt them and be in his spot right then. “How long did she say? Ten minutes?”

“Fifteen,” he grunted as he watched her move her damn panties to the side. Even from my spot on the chair, I could see how she was glistening. My mouth watered as I imagined her taste from last night, and my cock jerked once again when I thought about how she had taken my fingers so well.

Estrella chuckled. “Look at you boys. Do we need a stopwatch? Jesus. Maybe you won’t even last five minutes with that kind of attitude.”

I groaned. “You’re bullying.”

“Yeah,” she hummed. “And you like it.”

I absolutely fucking did.

Theo pulled her even closer and my teeth sank into my bottom lip as he dragged the tip of his cock up and down her slit before placing it right over her pelvis. “You see that? See how deep it’ll be inside you? You want that?”

“Oh my God. Please. That’s so…that’s hot.”

“Mhhm. Come here, pretty girl. What’s the time, Zack?”

Jesus.

I looked at the digital clock on the nightstand. “10:12 p.m.”

sixteen

ESTRELLA

Theo smirked above me as he rubbed the tip of his cock against my pussy, and I could have sworn that I felt a tremor pass through my legs every time that he brushed against the hood of my clit. “That means I have to last until 10:27 for our little bet. What do you say about that?”

I nearly blew him a raspberry. “Sé hacer matemáticas, idiota.”

One of his hands left my waist, slowly climbing until it was wrapped around my throat delicately. “Such a smart mouth. What do you say, Zack? Should we fill it to stop this never-ending attitude? Maybe we’ll finally get some peace and quiet.”

“At least I wouldn’t be in this fucking chair anymore,” Zack groaned.

I whimpered as Theo hit my clit again. I knew that I had to be leaving a wet spot on the comforter at that point. I raised my eyebrows at the man above me. “Such a dominant attitude when I’m vulnerable. Maybe I’ll put you in the chair next.”

He laughed, but it was quickly covered by the loud moan that tore out of my throat as I felt the tip of his dick slide into me.

Fuck. He was huge.

I obviously knew he looked huge, but looking and feeling were too completely different things.

“Yeah, baby?” Zack said from behind me. My head tipped back even more to look at him. And fuck—watching him jerk off to the sight of me, even at that odd upside down angle, had to be one of the hottest things I had ever seen. “Does he feel good? Just the tip and you’re moaning like a desperate little thing.”

“F-F-Fuck,” Theo groaned out before I could answer. “God, she feels so good. I’m not even halfway in. What the fuck.”

---