Page 36 of Contrition

I moaned again as he pulled out slightly, only to push in again. “Would you hurry up?”

His eyes snapped to mine with a hint of indignation. “One day, I will ruin this damn pussy. But you have never taken me before, so be a good fucking girl and let me work it in properly. Understood?”

The snort behind me was quick to follow. “She can take it. Look at her, dripping and shaking. All that attitude until a real man fucks her, right? Maybe she should beg. Right,mi Estrella? You sure knew how to beg for me when you had to cum last night. Do it again.”

I didn’t know if I wanted to stab them or bow down to them for how they were talking about me.

Somehow, regardless of my switchy soul, I think I needed both at that moment.

“P-Please. I need you to fuck me. I need this,” I begged, conceding. “I can take it. Just—please.”

Theo groaned, and I watched as his eyes bounced around before his teeth sank into his bottom lip. “Don’t beg. If you beg right now, I will breed this fucking pussy before you can say another word.”

“Por favor. Please fuck me properly.” My lips curled into a smile then as I reached down to wrap my hand around the leftover part of his shaft that I would still, somehow, have to take. “I need all of this in me. I’ll be a good girl for you.”

“You just want to win your damn bet, princess.”

“Yeah, I do. But I bet your dick twitches every time I tell you ho—" My sentence was cut off as his hand slapped down on my mouth, right as he shoved the rest of his cock in me abruptly. My eyes rolled into the back of my head, and I was genuinely surprised that a scream didn’t tear its way out of my throat either.

“Fuck!” Theo groaned.

I only whimpered against his hand before shifting my hips into him.

Maybe I had really bitten off more than I could chew. He was the biggest I had ever taken. It was unfair to the rest of society, and maybe even all the fictional boyfriends I had fallen in love with, too.

But fuck, I still somehow needed more.

“I know, baby. I know. I’m trying here.”

Zack’s chuckle mixed with his own groan. “You gonna make it, bro?”

“Fuck you.”

“Thought you said that was incest?”

My eyebrows pinched together at that round of banter.

Dear God, what had I gotten myself into? I really hoped that option was not on the table. I already had enough change in life events over the last two days.

Taking back my husband and fucking his brother, for example.

Theo’s hand only pressed down on my mouth harder as he began moving in and out of me slowly. My legs shook in their position, and my eyes rolled as I wrapped one of them around his waist. “Feel good, princess?”

I nodded my head, and my eyes nearly crossed as he shifted his body slightly, rubbing that spot inside of me that had me losing most of my brain cells.

A man who apparently loved me, was huge,andknew how to find the clit and g-spot?

I was a goner.

“That’s a good girl. You feel so good to me, too. Better than I ever could have imagined.”

Zack spoke behind me. “Just wait until the day we make her air-tight.”

Theo’s head tilted up to look at him. My moans only grew louder as he spoke and started to thrust in and out of me faster. “Air-tight? We’re never sharing this girl with anyone else ever again.”

“No, we aren’t. But we do believe in sex toys. And our girl is greedy. I bet we could make something work.”

Oh…my God.

---