Page 38 of Contrition

Everything.

I’d do everything.

“De-Deep end,” I moaned out, right as Zack’s fingers interlocked with mine. I squeezed roughly.

“Fuck!” Theo shouted, and I nearly cried as his hips flexed, positioning himself all the way in. I could feel him actually throbbing. “Fuck, yes! I’m coming. Take my seed, princess. Fuckkkkk.”

My eyes crossed between the mixture of all three of us.

Seconds passed as Theo slumped forward, covering my sweaty body with his. Compared to his fucking, his kisses on the side of my neck were soft and sensual.

Loving, even.

His cock still twitching inside of me was way too intense of a mixture for the kisses. Overstimulated didn’t even begin to describe how I was feeling, and the after-orgasm cry was probably seconds away.

At least, until it was Zack’s hand moving from my hand to my hair, and tugging it forcefully enough that I cried out. Theo chuckled as he spoke.

“My turn.”

seventeen

THEO

“You can’t give a guy any recovery time, can you?” I muttered as I continued pressing kisses into Estrella’s neck.

I couldn’t tell whether I should label myself as pathetic or whipped. Probably both.

That was the best sex of my fucking life.

And of course, it was with the girl who had consumed my thoughts for over a decade.

Zack hummed out his response. “Nope. You had a bet, didn’t you? Get it up, old man, or sit on the sidelines like I did. I’m fucking my wife whether it’s with or without you.”

Estrella whined. “What if I said I was sore? He is big, ya know.”

A strong gasp flew out of her throat as her neck craned away from me again. Zack definitely pulled her hair again, and likely harder than he had before. “I would tell you that you have now made me cum twice without even properly touching me, and third time is the fucking charm.”

I laughed deeply as I looked up at him. “Charming.”

Though, somehow, the idea of fucking Estrella with my brother at the same time only aroused me, and I felt myself growing rock hard in seconds. Estrella moaned when I thrusted in slightly, and I moaned right along with her.

Zack spoke again. “Have you done anal,mi Estrella? I won’t judge. Just need to know how much prep you need. I need this first time to be good for you.”

“Uhm…I’m okay.”

One of my eyebrows raised as I kept my eyes on her, even as my hips kept rocking. “What does that mean?”

“I’ve done anal.”

“Congratulations. Don’t be shy, though. How experienced are you with it?”

“...Very?”

I choked on my laugh, and I could have sworn that Zack’s face resembled one of a downright tomato. “Very?”

“Hey! You said you wouldn’t judge. And I didn’t want to settle down with anyone for the risk of kids. If there were no condoms, there were clean test results and anal. Just being safe, dickheads.”

I thrust inside of her more sharply that time. “Language, princess.”

---