Page 69 of Please Don't Leave Me

I laugh super hard because I can imagine the earful Liam got when Evie returned to her seat after waiting.

Everyone agrees that joining the Mile High Club would be super cool, but no one claps, and we move on to Tony.

“Never have I ever…had a dad.”

Umm, that was dark. But everyone still laughs to mask the awkwardness in the boat.

The rest of us clap.

That leaves Iris, Liam, Evie, and I all with one finger left. Tony and B both have two. I’m shocked B is doing so well. Usually, she’s the first one out by a long shot.

It’s my turn, so I say another one I always use. “Never have I ever...had a threesome.”

B claps, which is only a little shocking to me since she hasn’t mentioned it. The bigger shock is both Liam and Evie clapping and losing the game.

Iris looks over at her brother and sister-in-law, shocked by this revelation. “Excuse me? Tell!”

Evie and Liam look at each other, trying to hold back their grins and laughter, failing miserably.

"We'll let you use your imagination."

All of us stare at them with wide eyes and our mouths open. They smile and shrug.

Breaking the silence, Iris chimes in. “B, tell us your story! I know you're dying to share the details. Was it recent?”

“It was on New Year’s Eve with this gorgeous man and another bi girl. It was very steamy.”

Iris leans in. “More details, please. Do I know either of them?”

“I don’t think you do. The guy was named Cam, and I honestly don’t remember the girl's name. I only remember his because she kept moaning it over and over. But god, I don’t blame her; he was so hot.”

B goes on to describe the guy in detail. Realization slowly creeps in, and I burst out laughing. All eyes are on me, questioning.

I finally get enough air in my lungs to speak. “B, I’m pretty sure we hooked up with the same guy.”

“No fucking way. Are you serious?”

“Yeah, I met a guy named Cam on a dating app a few months after New Year’s. Oh my god, this is hilarious.”

Luckily, everyone else on the boat also finds it very funny. Some sisters might be grossed out by that, but I’m honestly not. We have very different tastes in men, so I never thought this would happen. But Cam is one of those people with a universally attractive face and a hot body, so it makes sense.

After we all calm down over the threesome, we remember that Liam and Evie both lost the game. They finish their drinks as punishment and crack another one for the next game.

Next, we move on to Truth or Dare. This game makes me nervous, but I’m tipsy, which helps.

B starts off by asking Liam, and he picks truth. Safe way to start.

“What is the kinkiest thing you and Evie have ever done?”

He thinks about it for a moment. “I guess maybe that ropes course we took last year.” He’s looking at Evie, waiting for her to correct him if there’s something else he’s missed. She doesn’t correct him. “Yeah, probably that. We went to a local adult store and took a little course on how to tie people up. It was actually really fun.” Evie nods in agreement.

Liam turns to me and asks, and I pick dare. Why not spice things up a bit?

“I dare you to kiss Tony.”

I look over at Tony, and he nods, indicating that he’s fine with it if I am. I crawl across the cushioned seat and grab the side of his face, angling it toward me. I brush my lips on his, and he kisses me back. It’s brief but long enough for me to realize that Ididn’t feel a spark at all. You know when you kiss someone, and it just feels wrong? Or when they touch you, and it almost annoys you instead of making your skin feel like it's on fire?

I’m not sure if some of the things I’ve learned about him tonight are causing it, but I have officially decided that I’m not going to pursue him in any way. I can’t tell how he feels about it.

---