Page 44 of Blind Justice

“Did he fuck you hard?”

She nodded. “Yes.”

“Did you scream for his dick?” Duncan’s gaze never left Enzo’s as he asked each question.

“Always,” she murmured.

“Always?” Duncan scrubbed his chin. “How about you, Enzo?”

“What about me, Master Duncan?”

Duncan sucked in a breath. “Good boy. You remembered.” The praise slipped off of his tongue. “Do you come inside your sister when you fuck?”

Bella whimpered.

“I do, Master Duncan. It feels good to nut inside my baby.”

Duncan’s dick throbbed. Arousal spiked in his system. “You’ve never allowed any other man the pleasure of coming inside your sister?”

Enzo shook his head. “No. Never. But, she’s not my sister. We have different parents.”

“So, I would be the second man in Bella’s life to leave my mark inside her?” He slid his gaze to Bella, gauging her reaction while ignoring Enzo’s statement. “Do you want my cum, Bella? Do you want to ride my dick until I empty myself within you? Or should I reserve that privilege for your brother?”

She licked her bottom lip. “Both.”

Duncan smirked. “Greedy. You’ve invited others to your bed before, haven’t you? Watched your brother get fucked and filled with cum.”

Her pulse throbbed at her throat. Her eyes were wide, swirling with lust. “Yes.”

“What do you like most, Bella? What turns you on?”

She cut her eyes to Enzo.

“Not him. Me,” Duncan snapped. “This is my apartment. You will answer my questions and do as I say, or you can end it all with your safeword, red.”

“What happens if I say red?” The open curiosity in her voice made it hard for Duncan to tell her the truth.

“Then I’ll leave and find someone else to care for the both of you until the trial.”

“Hermoso?” Enzo’s brown eyes met Duncan’s gaze. “Are you serious?”

“Yes.”

“Why?” Fear tinged Enzo’s voice.

“Because, I’m too old, Enzo. Because I walked into this situation blind. Because I fell for someone who isn’t available to me. Or, in this setting, shouldn’t be available to me.” He gave Bella his full attention then. “This is who I am, Bella. Either accept it or don’t.”

“There’s no gray for you, is there?” She tilted her head to the side. “Your life is black and white. Do or don’t. Nothing in between.”

“There are some areas of gray,” he replied. “In this, however, no. To accept me into your lives as a lover, you have to be willing to give yourselves over to me. To allow me to dictate how all of this goes. To be in charge of your pleasure and Enzo’s. You’ve only known Enzo’s desires as he has only known yours since you were teenagers. I will disrupt everything you know about sex. I will destroy your ideals, manipulate your desires, and reform your appetites to match mine. If you’re not willing to undergo such a drastic change, you have to tell me now. I need to be able to walk away with my head and heart intact.”

“What about ours?” Enzo lowered his head. “What happens to us if we don’t say yes to this?”

Duncan bent forward, placing his finger under Enzo’s chin. When their gazes met, Duncan sighed. “You’ll still have each other. I won’t tell anyone the truth.”

Surprise colored Enzo’s expression. “Why would you give up everything for us?”

“Unlike some, I won’t cage a bird.”

---