Page 86 of Caught Looking

She swallowed hard, her cheeks a perfect pink. “A water would be lovely.”

“Cool I’ll be right back. Hey, Willa’s on the way.”

“That’s wonderful news.” I added a second finger, pumping her harder and faster. “We haven’t gotten to spend a lot of time together lately.”

“I heard she got an interview with the Tangerines. She said you mentioned her to the owners.” Ev had a dreamy look on his face.

Did the fucker have a clue how much he was in love with Willa? Or would it take a hammer to the head before he figured it out?”

Luckily I had no such trouble. I fell for Annalise and went right after her. And now she was sitting in my lap, quiet as a mouse, while I fucked her with my fingers in front of my friend. “I did. I’m really glad they’re looking at her. I think Willa would be perfect for the project. She always had a knack for documentaries.”

“No shit.” Ev grinned even wider. “But she said there was no money in it. That’s why she went into film. Anyway. It would be cool if she got to stick around for a while. The three…fourof us together again.” She shot a wink at Annalise.

But all she could do was smile back because now I had her stuffed full of three fingers as my thumb strummed her clit.

“I’ll be right back with those waters.”

The moment Ev turned his back I growled, “You are such a good girl, Annalise. You didn’t make a sound when I stuffed your pussy full.”

She whimpered, her head lolling back.

“Taking my fingers in front of Everett with nothing but a pretty pink flush on your cheeks. Did you like it? Having him right there while I fucked you with my fingers?”

“Yes.” Another gorgeous, breathy moan.

I could do this all night. I could do this forever.

I pulled out, spreading her arousal everywhere, sliding through her slit, around her clit, and back again. I coated her lips and massaged her wishbone.

“When we get home tonight I’m going to reward you so well for this. I’m going to fuck you so hard, so deep.”

“Yes,” she moaned. “I want you to pound me with your monster cock until I black out.”

“What a sweet reward for being such a good girl,” I purred. “Quiet now. Everett’s back.” I shoved my fingers back inside her cunt and pumped once, twice. Then swiped my thumb over her swollen clit.

She pulsed around me and more of her slick arousal coated my fingers.

“If I’d realized how much this would turn you on I wouldn’t have waited so long.”

“Seth.”

“Here you go!” Everett held out two bottles of water. Annalise took them with shaking hands.

Not that I thought Everett noticed. He was too busy smiling and humming. “Can’t wait for Willa to get here. I think you’re going to fit right in, Annalise.”

“I’m looking forward to it,” she croaked out, just as I added my pinkie finger.

“Be back soon!” Ev waved as he left.

I stilled my fingers, letting her wet pussy sink down on my knuckles. “Pull down your top for me.” I took the water bottle from her hand.

Her eyes went wide. “No, Seth.”

“I just had it down a minute ago. You didn’t say no then. Pull. It. Down.”

Her fingers flew, exposing her nipple to me all over again. I locked eyes with her and watched her fight for control as I teased her nipple with the cold bottle. I tightened into a hard, red bud.

“Now the other.”

---