Page 48 of Social Sinners

“Feel free to use any of our toys, I can assure you all have been properly sanitized and will be again after tonight,” I informed them as I walked over to remove a riding crop from the rack, trailing the edge of it along Easton’s taint before flicking each of his balls. Benny stripped, and River went to the chest, returning with a dildo and lube. We had several bottles for just such occasions. We planned to host parties from time to time for some of the regulars we knew from the club, so we always wanted to have plenty on hand.

I continued trailing the crop across Easton’s skin, reaching his pebbled nipples. Flicking them, he moaned again before I lightly tapped the head of his cock with the tanned leather. Firmly fisting it, I gave him a couple rough tugs, drawing the foreskin over the head. Had he not been wearing the cock ring, I know those actions alone would’ve had him shooting like a geyser.

To my right, River and Mickey were securing Benny in the swing at the center of the room. Mickey was a bit unsure but followed River’s lead without a spoken word between the three of them. I enjoyed the silence for which they worked as a team, but if they had any questions at all, I would’ve gladly answered them.

River began to undress, and reluctantly, Mickey did the same. I could see the blush on his face and neck from where I stood. Not wanting him to be uncomfortable in this setting, I, in turn, removed my clothes as well. I’d never been one to shy away from nudity as it was, but it was important to me that he feel comfortable. I watched as they lubed Benny’s exposed hole first, then the dildo. Mickey stroked himself and Benny at the same time as River teased Benny’s entrance with the tip of the rubber toy, pressing in slightly before pulling back and pushing it in again. Benny’s moans had me fisting my own cock and stroking it as I continued watching them.

Never in a million years did I picture myself in this setting until the day we showed them our room and Benny’s face lit up. These guys were brothers to me, but they were humans as well, and I enjoyed watching others fuck as much as I got off on being watched. I needed to view this interaction as nothing more than a club setting with strangers.

I removed the plug from Easton’s ass, and he again whimpered. Kneeling beneath him, I watched as his pucker muscles retracted before plunging my tongue inside him. Thoroughly, I orally fucked him until my spit dripped from his crack. With the increase in moans, I knew he’d reached the breaking point, and I slid my dick inside him in one thrust, grasping the cock ring he had on and slid it off.

“Are you ready baby?”

“Yes, Master,” he moaned. Glancing over my shoulder, Mickey was feeding Benny his cock while River was buried balls deep inside his ass. The dildo had long since been tossed aside. All three eyes were glued to Easton and I as I pulled back, slamming into him and forcing him to gasp. I wound my fingers through his hair, pulling his head back and fucked him hard.

“Do not come until I tell you to, understood?” I ordered him.

“Ugh, yes Master,” he agreed, but his tone and clenched jaw told me he was not happy with my request.

With one hand gripping his hair and the other jacking his cock, I pounded his ass several more times before relenting, “Easton, come. Now!” I pushed inside him as deeply as I could, his channel contracted around me, constricting the blood flow and sending both of us over the edge. His pulsating cock released, running over my fist as we both yelled, “Fuck!” at the same time.

Mickey and River both came with a grunt as I watched Benny’s release coat his abdomen. As quickly as I could, I unshackled Easton and carried his spent body over to the aftercare area. Retrieving both bottles of water and the blanket from the back of the couch to cover us with while I cradled his limp body in my arms. We finished our water, tossing the bottles aside while we came down from our euphoric high.

Collectively, we spent the better part of the next hour taking care of our partner's needs in silence. It wasn’t uncomfortable, in fact, I was rather proud of the way Mickey and River took care of Benny.

“How do you guys feel about what took place tonight?” I asked them.

“I won’t deny that it was awkward at first,” Mickey began, “but once I quit overthinking it and lived in the moment that all changed for me.”

“Benny? River?” I wanted to hear their take on things too. A repeat hinged on all parties being in agreement.

“This wasn’t our first time,” River replied. “Benny and I have been in group settings before.”

“Nice. Mickey, do you think you’d be interested in joining us again?” I was confident after hearing River’s answer that they would be down for it, but Mickey would need to feel the same way.

“Joey and Stoli never hear about this, right?” He asked.

“As I said at the door before we even came in here, what happens in this room stays in this room,” I reminded him.

“Then yeah, I’m down.”

---