“I’m ready,” I whimpered.
He lifted his upper body and looked into my eyes. “Condoms?”
“Hell no. Not with you guys,” I said. We were all on PrEP religiously and had kept tabs on one another throughout the years. I trusted no one but them.
“Atta boy,” Tanner said, then scrambled to the side where his backpack was and rummaged until he found a small bottle that made me want to laugh out loud. “Not that I planned this,” he said guilelessly and shrugged, waving the bottle of lube around. “You just never know when you’ll have a moment alone and feel like fooling around with yourself.”
Laughing in the middle of this felt so much different than ever before. These were my people, my friends, my lovers. I could laugh with them even when we were all naked and dirty.
Tanner winked in my direction as he poured some lube over his fingers and his dick, stroked himself, then rubbed my hole gently.
Damien distracted me with kisses, pulling my knees further up and lifting my ass for Tanner.
“Ready?” Tanner asked, massaging my rim gently.
“Uh-huh,” I managed and immediately felt him fill me with one slim finger. It entered me smoothly, painlessly, lubing me all the way in. By instinct, I tensed, my hole clenching for a moment and Tanner stopped. But a heartbeat later, I was relaxed again and Tanner resumed the slow movements with his hand.
Carefully, he pushed another finger inside of me, spitting on my hole more for the kink of it than any true use, and heat released inside my chest and flushed my face. His moves were quicker and I moaned into Damien’s open mouth, our tongues playing, wrestling, caressing, battling.
Tanner pulled his hand out so smoothly that I barely felt a thing, my hole closing quickly until I forced myself to relax. Without looking, I felt Tanner’s movements and I knew he was positioning himself over me. So when I felt the slick tip of his cock touching my hole, I didn’t flinch.
I also didn’t hold back any of the moans that loaded and welled in me. They poured out and over Damien’s lips as Tanner pushed his cock into me. He was gentle enough to feel my body’s reaction and find my limits, pulling back and adjusting for another slow swing of his hips and filling me deeper. In a minute, he was balls deep inside of me and I was breathless and swimming in a sea of lust and desire.
Tanner, comfortably in me now, grabbed my ankles roughly, relieving Damien of his duty, and spread my legs a little, panting as he fucked me quicker and harder. Damien, at the same time, rose to his knees and kissed Tanner, right hand on Tanner’s ass and left reaching for my cock. He didn’t stroke me, but he held me firmly, his thumb occasionally brushing the tip and feeling the silver bead of precum that perpetually formed and grew over the slit.
“Fuck me harder,” I pleaded and watched my two boys smile while kissing one another. Damien spanked Tanner hard and I could have sworn I felt it vibrate up to my chest.
My heart was pounding in my throat while Tanner rammed me and did as he had promised. He was moving my legs and lifting my ass, fucking me from different angles to stretch me for Damien.
“Go fill his mouth,” Tanner told Damien with a smirk.
“Fuck yes,” I begged. “Fill my mouth, Damien.”
My first love and oldest friend didn’t hesitate. He knelt to my right and gently turned my head to face him. I opened my mouth, heart tripping and skipping as he brought his massive cock near my face. No matter how wide I opened my mouth, I knew he wasn’t fitting it all the way in. Perhaps not even two thirds of the way.
His thickness filled my mouth and reached for the back of my throat with force, cutting off the flow of air. I didn’t pay it any attention. Who the hell needed air anyway? I wanted to fucking choke on him until the last moment and feel the relief when he pulled back just enough to let me breathe.
With Tanner pounding my ass and Damien filling my mouth, I discovered something completely new. I discovered a level of sex that finally, for the first time in so many years of hooking up and fooling around, felt right. It was finally enough.
I quickly figured that it had nothing to do with the number of people, but with the very fact who these people were. I’d been shared by them all my adult life. I’d been theirs for as long as I could remember and it was only natural that I was now between them. And that they would share me in real life was the ultimate fantasy coming true.
I felt Tanner nearing his orgasm. I didn’t know how, but I knew it was true. His moves were more determined and his panting was quickening. Damien, probably also feeling it, pulled his cock out of my mouth and slapped Tanner’s ass hard. And when he rubbed the sore spot, I watched Tanner lift his head. All of Tanner’s muscles were flexing, sweat covering his body and hair a total mess. He rammed into me, biting his lower lip, then smirking. “Yeah,” he huffed at Damien. “Play with my ass. Fuck yes.”
I finally heard myself moaning again when reality sank in. I was holding the blanket on either side of my waist and pushing the back of my head into it while Tanner wrecked me.
“Fuck, I’m gonna come,” Tanner said.
I felt him pull back, but I grabbed his hips. “Fill me,” I hissed. “Fill my fucking hole.”
His gaze caught mine and fire burned a thousand times brighter suddenly. A flash of adoration washed over his face as he sped up the thrusting of his hips and throbbed hard and fast inside of me, filling me with his heat and dropping his head back in ecstasy.
Tanner didn’t slow down for a full fucking minute, slamming into me long after his cock stopped pulsing and shooting his cum inside of me. But the warmth, literal or purely in my imagination, spread throughout my body without stopping.
When Tanner finally pulled his cock out, he was panting in shallow breaths and almost shaking. “Fucking. Hell.” It was all he said before he collapsed next to me and pressed his lips hard against mine. Then, he looked at Damien and grinned. “He’s all yours.”
Damien looked at me as if he needed some confirmation. I felt my love for them both double in that instant. As if there was any force on the planet that would make me change my mind now. I nodded. I nodded hard and pulled my own legs back for him.
Damien reached for the lube and didn’t spare it. His cock was at full mast and already slick with saliva and precum, and I was slick with Tanner’s cum, but he still rubbed plenty of lube all over it before slowly and carefully pressing the tip against my hole.