"You might be shortsighted," Jay said. He pushed my bra off and let it drop to the side.
"Definitely not," Atlas said. He pushed me down gently onto my back and undid my skirt before pulling it and my panties off. "I have an idea, if both of you are game."
"Is he actually asking permission?" I said, directing the question to Jay.
"He seems to be," Jay agreed.
Atlas narrowed his eyes at us before pushing his pants off and kicking them aside. "When you put it that way… Jay, get naked. I'm getting the lube." He helped off the bed and over tohis open suitcase, returning a moment later with a tube in his hand. "We're going to need lots of this." He opened the lid.
My heart skipped a beat with anticipation of what he might be thinking. So far, none of them suggested anything I didn't want to do with enthusiasm. I suspected that would be the case now too.
"Jay, lie on your back," Atlas ordered. "Chelsea, you too. Spread your legs." He gestured for me to open them wide.
I lay down beside Jay and bent my knees, opening them so far my knees touched the bed covers.
"I love how fucking flexible you are." Atlas squirted some lube onto his fingers and smeared it around my already wet pussy. He squirted out more and slathered it all over Jay's cock, then more on his own.
"Chelsea, ride Jay's cock and lean forward as far as you can."
I glanced at Jay to make sure he was okay with this so soon after what happened at the airport. When he nodded eagerly, I straddled him, lowering myself down onto his cock.
"Lean forward a bit more," Atlas said. He straddled Jay's legs behind me and moved in close. "That's it." He pressed the head of his cock to my entrance, right beside Jay's.
"Have you ever taken two cocks in your pussy at the same time before?" Atlas asked. His voice was rough with need.
"Never," I said with some trepidation. Both of them were so big, they were going to stretch me to my limit. Could I do this? I was willing to try. I'd never backed down from a challenge yet; why start now?
"Good, because you're about to." Atlas pushed himself in a little more.
At first, my muscles tensed reflexively, trying to resist the extra pressure. I forced myself to relax and let him press in deeper still. Bit by bit, he eased himself until they were both all the way inside me.
"Holy shit," Jay whispered. "That feels so… Fucking… Incredible. I can feel both of you, like…" He shook his head, out of words to describe the way it felt.
"Amazing," I whispered. I'd felt full before, but never like this. Never with two thick cocks so deep inside me, pressed up against each other.
"Next level," Atlas agreed. Very slowly and very carefully, he started to move his hips back and forth, creating friction without letting himself fall back out.
"Why haven't we done this before?" Jay whispered.
"Because we didn't have Chelsea before," Atlas said. That was all the explanation he gave and none of us asked for anything more. Honestly, I couldn't have conjured too many coherent words anyway. This was like nothing I ever experienced before, and I'd experienced a lot.
As Frost would say, this was definitely something I wanted to put on the menu to do later. He and Storm would be down for it, as would Frost and Jay together. Would it feel different with different combinations of my guys? I looked forward to finding out.
"I'm going to come," Jay said, his voice strained.
"Me too," I said, just as strained.
"Yeah, me too," Atlas said, sounding slightly disappointed in himself. Of course, this was his first time doing this as well. With practice, we could hold out for longer. I'd happily fuck like this for hours. Or try to, anyway. With the pressure on my clit and all the way through me, keeping myself from coming might be a hell of a challenge. One I was happy to face head on. So to speak.
For now, I let myself go, tumbling over into the abyss, my muscles tightening further around both of them and making them both come, spilling themselves around each other. Filling my pussy to overflowing with their cum.
"I can feel…everything," Jay said, groaning out his orgasm. "I felt Atlas come."
"I felt you come," Atlas said, like it was some kind of revelation. It might have been. "I've fucked before, but now I dunno… It's like fucking both of you at the same time is… Epic."
"I know what you mean," I said. I thought I'd done pretty much everything I could do, but I was wrong. There was always more to do and more to learn. And more to enjoy.
I was one lucky girl.