Tanner looked so happy. I stared over at the girls again. Was he happy because of the hot Society girls he’d brought? My stomach twisted into knots.
I wasn’t allowed to be jealous after what I’d just done. And yet...I still felt it. I tried to shake the thought away. Tanner wasn’t getting gangbanged by these bikini sluts. I had nothing to be jealous of. I took a deep breath and walked over to him.
“There she is!” said Zico. “I was just telling Johan about the little game we played while he was out.”
I gulped.Oh God.What had he said? I wanted to tell Tanner the story in his masturbatorium. Not here. “You did?” My voice came out all squeaky and weird.
Tanner smiled up at me. “He did indeed. So Luigi was your favorite, huh?”
How did they know that?! I hadn’t said anything. Had I moaned extra loud with him? Anyway, they were wrong. I shook my head. “Nope. Pickpocket was the best.”
“I was, huh?” There was a twinkle in Pickpocket’s eye.
“I didn’t realize Pickpocket had taken a dive,” said Tanner.
“I didn’t,” said Pickpocket. “I think she’s referring theothergame we played.”
“What other game?” asked Tanner.
Ahhhhh!They hadn’t told him?Gah!My throat made another weird squeaking noise. I had to come clean. Even though I didn’t have any pics, I could at least tell him the truth. “The lads had a size contest,” I said. Why was I suddenly talking like Zico and Duke? It was like once a British dick entered you, you had tostart speaking their tongue. I cleared my throat. “If you’d come back a few minutes earlier, you would have found me on my knees with Pickpocket’s big black cock all the way down my throat.”
Tanner laughed. “Well I can hardly blame him when you’re in a bikini like that. Did you not like the one I picked out for you?”
What?“This is the one you picked out for me.”
He gave me a funny look. And then he looked down at my heels. “No. Definitely not.”
I followed his line of sight. He was staring at the back of my heels. That weren’t the signature Odegaard blue. Tanner only ever bought me Odegaards.
Oh.
Fuck.
Ghazi must have been messing with me. That little asshole!I was wrong to compare him to Nigel. Nigel was helpful. Ghazi was the exact opposite. He was a manipulative little twat waffle!
Tanner shrugged and started talking to his teammates again.
And I realized he didn’t believe a word I’d just said.
I did my best to enjoy the rest of the pool party. It was fun now that Tanner was here.
He pulled me onto his lap and wrapped his arm protectively around my waist.
Okay, no, it wasn’t fun. It was awkward as hell. Because every guy here except for Tanner had just been deep inside of me.
Zico winked at me.
Everyone stop fucking winking!
I tried to pretend nothing weird had just happened. But I was pretty sure I was just acting weirder than ever.
I’d done it though. I’d fucked the whole team. And even though Tanner hadn’t sent the bikini, he’d previously said he wanted that. Specifically at a pool party. He totally wanted this. And I’d been so good and fucked so many potential lesser true love matches! I couldn’t wait to get home to check his lamp. I was feeling really good about this. All these guys were hot. Any other girl would be crazy not to be madly in love with one of them. Just not this girl, because I’d already found my soulmate. But odds were, I’d just found my lesser true love!
True Love - Chapter 4 – Tracking Karima
Saturday – November 4, 2023
Tanner