“It’s best to start with me,” he said. “I’m the closest in size to your boyfriend, so it’ll be an easy transition for you.”
“Good point,” she said and stroked his cock. She started to drop to her knees, but then she popped back up and let go of him.
And then she was on her knees in front of the final guy. The one with the birthmark. And his cock was down her throat.
“Looks like she’s made her choice,” I said.
She nodded on his cock.
“Seriously?” asked Anthony. “You chose the biggest one?”
She got back up. “I just thought it would be less awkward since I already know him. It’s so naughty to just bend over and let a complete stranger fuck me. And anyway, he’s the second biggest. Mr. King is still going to fuck me, right?”
I nodded. “Absolutely. I just thought it would be courteous to let the boys warm you up first.”
“So thoughtful,” she said and handed Birthmark her leash.
He spun her around and pushed on her back to bend her over.
Maeve’s eyes got huge as he slowly slid his massive cock inside of her.
“Wait!” yelled Anthony. He ran around over and looked in horror at the huge cock half way in his fiancée’s pussy.
“What’s wrong?” asked Birthmark.
“Did you seriously not put a condom on?”
“No.”
Anthony put his hand on his forehead. “Fuck man, I haven’t even gotten to do that yet.”
Oh shit.
“Well then you’re in for a treat,” said Birthmark. “Her pussy feels fucking fantastic.” He pulled on her hips and slid into her more.
“Dude, stop!”
“Babe,” said Maeve. “It’s fine. I’m on birth control. And I doubt they make condoms big enough for him.”
I walked over and put my arm around Anthony’s shoulders. “Don’t worry, it’s not like he’s going to cum in her. Single Boy Rule #27: Unless you’re dating, always finish on her face or tits.”
She arched her back and pressed against him.
“I’ll try my best,” said Birthmark. “But with an ass like this…no promises.” He slapped her ass and slammed into her pussy.
“This is fucked up,” said Anthony. “He’s not even testing the outfit.”
“Right,” said Maeve, looking back at the guy fucking her. “You’re supposed to fuck me so hard that my bikini top breaks.”
“I can do that,” said Birthmark. He grabbed the bikini strap across her back and increased his pace. Within a few thrusts, he was fucking her mercilessly.
Her moans got louder with every thrust.
It was just as hot as any of the banana party footage we had. And yet…I was still thinking of Ash. It was a good thing she wasn’t here though, because there was no way I could have shared her.
“Harder,” Maeve panted.
He pulled as far back as possible and slammed into her at full force. The bikini strap snapped and her entire body shook with pleasure.