Page 28 of Same Girl
“Has he ever been inside that ass?” Fyve asked, watching me closely.
“No.” I saw the smirk on his lips, and though I hated that Chosen had to find out this way, I knew it was about to happen. “Don’t you think it’s time to let him inside of that ass?”
Fyve moved off the bed and grabbed some lube from my panty drawer. He knew just where I kept those things because he was an ass man himself. Fyve was the first and only man who ever penetrated me back there.
They both had things that they owned about my body that the other had never been exposed to. Just as I had never done anal with Chosen, I had never given Fyve a blowjob until yesterday.
“Let me see you get on ya hands and knees for daddy,” Fyve ordered. I did as he instructed and moaned as the cool liquid dropped into my asshole.
“You want double penetration, li’l baby?”
“Mm-hmm.” I moaned.
Fyve cupped my jaw and kissed me deeply. “Now turn around and get on his dick.”
I positioned myself with my knees on either side of Chosen and my back to him. I didn’t want to see his face or deal with how he felt about me having anal with Fyve and not him—not right now. I slowly and cautiously worked my ass onto his dick as he guided me. It took a few times to align myself just right and to get into a comfortable position with him.
After Chosen impaled me, Fyve spread my legs up and out as wide as they would go.
“Damn. I love your pink, baby girl,” he mumbled, slipping his finger through my folds.
My eyes closed as I basked in the feeling of him playing in my sex while Chosen slowly pumped into me from behind.
“Mm. Baby, you’re so tight,” Chosen grunted through gritted teeth.
“That ass feels right, don’t it, man?”
“Fuck yeah. Aww, shit, baby,” Chosen whispered as he slowly pumped up.
“How does it feel to you, pretty mama?” Fyve asked.
“Sooo good.” I moaned as Chosen took his time with me, filling me up from the rear. We found a groove that worked for me, and I dropped my head back in anticipation of how Fyve would up the ante. Having a threesome had always been a fantasy of mine, but having it come true was next-level shit. The most amazing part was that I was having it with two men whom I loved.
Fyve continued watching for a couple of more minutes before he joined us on the bed. “You ready for me, baby?”
“Yes, Fyve.”
“Let me have all that pink, ma,” Fyve stated as he slid his girth along my folds. Our eyes connected, but mine dropped to half-mast when he pushed himself inside of me. The driving force of his hips sank him deeper inside of me, and Chosen stopped. He massaged my breasts and kissed the back of my neck.
My body was reclined against his, and though I felt the full force of him inside of my ass, it was Fyve’s strokes that propelled me to the edge. My body closed around him, gripping him into a snug fit, begging him never to release.
Chosen’s fingers over my nipples, pinching, tugging, and soothing, drove me insane. Fyve reached forward and gripped my neck. He choked me as he slow stroked me deep, hard, and slow before he picked up speed. The alternating sensations on my neck from Fyve’s aggressive choking and Chosen’s sensual kisses were hypnotic.
Chosen grunted underneath me as Fyve rutted inside me. I knew that Chosen felt the movement as well. With the little skin dividing the sections they penetrated, there was no way that they did not feel the other one sliding inside of me.
“Get deep in that ass, Chosen,” Fyve grunted as he slowed his thrusts.
Chosen picked up speed where Fyve left off, and he plunged deep into my ass.
“Oh shit! You’re gonna tear me, baby.”
“That’s what you get for holding out on that ass from him, pretty mama,” Fyve stated as he thumbed my clitoris while giving tiny pulses of his dick deep in my pussy.
“Ohhh! I cannot hold it in.” I cried out with my teeth clenched together.
“Gimme that pussy, li’l mama,” Fyve grunted as he shifted forward and rocked hard up into me. The intensity and pace of his movements were insane. His hazelnut-colored face turned a deep shade of brownish red, much like it did when he used to be on the football field. He grunted, and I knew he was almost over the edge. Tightening my pussy around him and pumping up, I helped him.
“Fuck yeah.” He grunted through clenched teeth, pulled his dick free, and squirted all over me.
