Page 46 of For the Plot

Page List

Font Size:

From there, I was a moaning, whining mess. Occasionally, he continued to smack my ass in varying degrees, and each time, I cried out, clenching around him.

“I’m close, Nikki,” he panted, his rhythm beginning to falter as he lost himself inside me. “Touch yourself, please. Come with me.”

Wasting no time, I snaked a hand down under me until I could reach my clit and rub in firm, tight circles. The combination of his cock hitting that one spot inside me while I touched my clit pushed me right up to the edge, my thighs shaking, knees in danger of buckling at the pleasure of it all.

“James!” I cried out. “I’m gonna come.”

After a few more frantic thrusts, James stilled inside me. “Fuck!” he roared as he came, his dick throbbing inside of me. That sensation is what finally sent me over the edge. I came around him, his dick inside me as my pussy clenched down on him dragging the orgasm out.

After a moment, James gently pulled out of me, the feeling of it drawing a soft whine from me. He rolled me over into his arms so he could hold me face-to-face and place a gentle kiss on my forehead before guiding me to lay on the mattress.

I watched through half-lidded eyes as he went to dispose of the condom. “I’ll be right back," he promised, holding my gaze until I nodded that I had heard him. He came back with a warm, wet cloth, and cleaned up between my legs, tossing it into the dirty hamper. He climbed in bed next to me, spooning me the way he had the first time.

I closed my eyes at the sweet kiss he pressed to the back of my neck. “How do you feel?”

I sighed contentedly, settling into his arms as my eyes drifted closed. “Perfect.”

27

James

Same Boat - Lizzy McAlpine

Overthenexttwoweeks, if I wasn't working and we had the apartment to ourselves, we were fucking. Anywhere and everywhere.

One day, Nikki blew me in the shower and made me come so hard I nearly slipped and brought us both down, out laughter bouncing off the shower walls. I fucked her from behind over the back of the couch while the movie we were watching played on in the background, forgotten. I ate her out on top of the dining table after she asked me what I wanted for dinner one night and I responded,you. We made sure to disinfect it thoroughly afterwards.

But it was starting to become more than just sex, at least for me. I fully gave up on denying it to myself any longer. I was in love with Nikki. Fully, madly, deeply in love with her. I tried not to let myself get my hopes up too much that she could feel the same, but sometimes I swore she looked at me differently. Like more than a friend.

Like the other day, when we’d had a rare night of SoCal rain. All four of us had been in our own rooms, and I looked out the window to see the rain coming down. I hoped the guys were already asleep, and I snuck to Nikki’s room after texting to see if she was awake. When she opened her door, I held a finger up to my lips, grabbing her hand and dragging her out of the apartment. She followed behind me, confused but giggling all the same. I led her out onto the street until we were standing in the rain, immediately soaked to the bone.

She asked me what I was doing, but before she could finish the sentence, I’d grabbed her by the face, pulling her in for a deep kiss. She reached up and grabbed my wrists, melting into the warmth of my mouth on hers. I'd bitten her lip, pulling away to rest my forehead against hers.

“Another box to check off your list,” I whispered.

I saw a look in her eyes that night I’d never seen before. Maybe it was all in my head. Maybe I was delusional for thinking she would ever love me back. But I had to try. And I had an idea.

What are you doing tonight?

I assume you’re looking for an answer other than you?

I’ve created a horny monster

Please, you can’t take credit for what I’ve always been

I concede*cry laughing emoji*

For real, though, why?

I had an idea

I think we should go on a date

A fake date, for research purposes

I have been on dates before you know

Yes, but have any of them been good?