Page 73 of How to Break My Heart 1
My muscles tense as my heart beats strongly, causing me to hold my breath while waiting in anticipation. With the pull of my belt, Everleigh unzips my pants until my boxers are visible.
I unbutton my shirt, exposing my chest, only for her to pull my boxers down, allowing my cock to spring free.
Her eyes widen. She gulps, then whispers, “You’re so… so… hard.”
There isn’t a second to respond as she takes me deep into her mouth.
A groan escapes me as I watch her wrap her tongue around my shaft to take me all in. Saliva builds around her mouth, and the delicious sounds make me clench because I’m ready to fucking explode.
Just as I’m about to remove her sweats and make her sit on top of me like a good cowgirl, a knock on the door startles us.
“Fuck!” Everleigh pants, pulling back in panic. “Um… who is it?”
“It’s Maddy. Hurry up, I really need to pee.”
Her mouth falls open as she stands in a mad rush. Beside us on the sofa, there’s a dark sweater that she reaches out for to put on before she says, “Oh my God. You need to get out of here.”
“I can’t get out of here,” I inform her while sliding my cock back into my boxers, zipping my pants carefully. “Who do you think I am, Spider-Man?”
When I’m done with my pants, she reaches for my arm, pushing me to the bathroom, eyes wide with fear. “Hide in there.”
“I’m not hiding in there. Relax, Madelina won’t suspect anything. We’ll just say we were discussing the wedding.”
“Aston,” she begs.
“Answer the door, Everleigh,” I demand again, annoyed my sister has cockblocked the night.
Everleigh turns on the light and runs to the door. “Sorry, I just got home from the grocery store. Well, ran home because I was so cold.”
Madelina’s voice gets closer. “Is that why your cheeks are red?”
“Yes, have you ever run up my steps?” Everleigh questions.
“Uh, yes, I just did because I need to pee…” Madelina pauses, then glances behind Everleigh, frowning at the sight of me. “What areyoudoing here?”
“I was waiting for Everleigh,” I lie, then smile forcefully. “We agreed to meet tomorrow to sort out the cars for the wedding, but I have a meeting, so I thought I’d drop by now to see if she could squeeze me in.”
Madelina observes both of us, but given that she is my sister and I’ve known her my whole life, she doesn’t suspect anything. The twinkle in her eye would suggest she thinks we’re planning something special for her wedding. A surprise, as such.
Everleigh casually sits beside me, tucking her feet under her legs. “Yeah, I was at the grocery store with Marco.”
Great! This is the one lie I don’t want to get on board with.
Madelina claps her hands with excitement. “Wait, so hot doctor is back on?”
“Yes, it’s back on.” Everleigh forces a smile, then continues, “I was just telling Aston about my upcoming date.”
I do everything to remain calm, sporting a blank face rather than exposing my jealousy. While I want to show Everleigh how Ireallyfeel about this, her pleas to keep this from my sister are in the back of my mind.
“Oh my goodness, I’m so excited,” Madelina squeals annoyingly. “You’re going to have the hottest sex ever. You think he will wear his white coat, and you’ll do it on his desk?”
The muscles in my neck tighten as I mutter, “Don’t you need to use the bathroom?”
“Oh, damn. Hold that thought.”
Madelina rushes to the bathroom, leaving me alone with Everleigh. The apartment is small, with the bathroom only a few steps away.
“I had to lie,” Everleigh whispers. “Don’t give me that look.”
