Page 79 of My Favorite Secret
“Fuck, baby.Fuck.” Tyler groans at the depth. “Are you okay? You didn’t need to do that.”
The sensation of his cock filling me is unlike anything I’ve experienced. It hurts so bad, yet the closeness between us is everything I need. His heart beats against my chest, grounding me in the moment. I close my eyes and take deep breaths, resting my forehead to his as I try to relax my muscles and adjust to his size.
“I’m fine,” I whisper, trembling from both the pain and intense emotions. “Give me a second.”
I attempt to focus on other sensations, like how much I love the feel of his warm skin against mine. The sound ofour breath mixing as one. The way his muscles tense and relax beneath me.
After a few deep breaths, the pain starts to fade. I feel his cock flex inside me, and a spark of pleasure spreads through me, remembering that we’re doing this with no condom. His pre-cum is coating me. Soon, I’ll be filled with his cum. I want to be filled by Tyler so badly.
After another deep breath, I open my eyes, never breaking our gaze as I slowly rise and sink back down. We both groan. I’m tender but the pain is easing.
“I’m losing my mind right now, Harper. Tell me this is real. You’re all I’ve ever wanted.”
“So real.” My voice wavers, overwhelmed by how connected I feel to him right now.
“You feel incredible.”
I love hearing that I please him. Tyler grabs my hips, helping me find my rhythm. Our movements are slow, but each time I lower, I moan with pleasure, feeling the tip of his cock a little deeper, stretching me farther.
Tyler strokes my clit and sucks my nipple. I gasp at the unexpected thrill that courses through me. My head tilts back and my eyelids fall shut, consumed by the connection between us.
When I open my eyes again, my attention catches on something moving in the distance—a figure standing within the shadows of a passageway.
I gasp, realizing Felix is watching me. A rush of panic hits me, fearful that he’s jealous. But then I see the dark pleasure in his eyes. The obsession.
Slowly, he steps into the clearing. “Does it feel good, Harper?”
Tyler turns his head, finding our company. Iexpect him to be frustrated with Felix for interrupting us. I’m shocked when he returns to kissing my breasts and rubbing my clit.
“Should we stop?” I ask Tyler. “Is this weird?”
“He’s watching you, not me.”
“I know but…”
“You’re ours, Harper. He has every right to watch.”
Felix told me Tyler has an unhinged side. I thought I understood what that meant. I thought I’d seen it last night. But it’s only now sinking in that while Felix has boundaries, Tyler truly does not. Witnessing this side of him makes my pussy clench around his cock.
He kisses my other nipple. “Perhaps it’s selfish of me to keep your first time all to myself. Ride me, baby. Enjoy yourself. Let him watch you. I know you love being watched.”
My eyes flick to Felix. While he’s not physically a part of this moment, he’s here to watch me lose my innocence, and somehow, this feels just as intimate. The sex is no longer only about me and Tyler, but the three of us, and it’s perfect.
I rise to the tip of Tyler’s cock, maintaining eye contact with Felix as I sink back down. The look in his eyes is feral, like he’s fighting with everything inside him to not join in.
Felix brushes a hand over his cock and groans. “You two are as sick as each other.”
“Yet you’re the one watching,” Tyler calls to him.
“I couldn’t miss out on her first time, even if it’s not with me.” Felix takes a seat on a stone bench, maintaining his distance. “Tell me what she feels like.”
Tyler holds my face between his two palms, looking me in the eyes, consumed with me, groaning as I move up and down on him. “She’s so tight around my cock. So warm. Ican feel each time her pussy flutters. She’s going to make me come so hard.”
“I bet. I can’t wait for my turn.”
I love the way they’re talking to each other about me. It spreads heat all through me, making me shiver. Tyler groans, and I wonder if he felt my pussy flutter again.
“She looks warmed up,” Felix says. “I think she can take it a little faster now.”
