Page 43 of Ugly Duckling
She cleared her throat. “Yes.”
“That’s because I came inside you,” I explained. “I slip in so easily now. I could use our own wetness to my advantage and slip inside a different hole.”
She hissed. “I’m not…I’ve never…”
I grinned. “Maybe not this time then.”
She bent over farther, the end of her ponytail dipping back into the hot water in front of her.
I caught both of her hips in my hands and really started to fuck her.
The wet slap-slap of our hips meeting, paired with the groans that I was pulling from her lips, was enough to have my balls drawing up.
“Hope you’re close,” I growled. “I’m going to fill you back up again.”
She looked over her shoulder at me, biting her lip, and I lost it.
I groaned as I came for a second time inside of her.
It was the goddamn best feeling in the world.
I hadn’t had condom-free sex since I was a teen, and when I was with Aleah, she felt nothing like this.
Sutton was so goddamn tight and hot.
Then her pussy started clenching, and I praised the Lord above for making her come.
I didn’t want her to ever not come when I was inside of her.
“Oh god,” she cried out. “I’m coming!”
Yeah, she was.
Her pussy spasmed and pulled the rest of the cum from my balls, causing me to hiss out a breath.
“I don’t think I’ve ever felt something like that in my life.”
I hadn’t either.
Fuck.
Nine
I’m so sad I need a shoulder to put my legs on.
—Sutton’s secret thoughts
SUTTON
It took me a week to come to terms with the fact that I’d had sex with my high school crush…and liked it.
It took me another week to gather the courage to reach out to Gunner and tell him that I wanted to move in with him.
It took me yet another week to gather up my meager belongings at my mom’s house and pack my car.
“Are you sure you have to go today? It’s kind of late.”
I looked at my mom and scrunched up my nose at her. “Mom, it’s eight in the morning.”
