“Like what you see, Ladybug?” I run my hand over her ass cheek and barely put pressure on the plug. “This is hot as fuck.”
She turns to look at me, and her pupils are blown. “Sean’s been changing the size all day.”
“Tell them why, Dragonfly.”
Her face turns red from being turned on and embarrassed. “So someone can fuck me there.”
“Fuck you where, Cupcake?”
“My ass.”
I start manipulating the plug, fucking her with it. Her whole body shudders, and her moan echoes off the wall. “You’re so goddamn beautiful. Turn around and let Kai slide inside that pussy.” We help her get turned around, and she slides down onto Kai without hesitation. “You like his cock, Ladybug?”
“Yes,” she moans, rocking her hips. “I need more.”
I grab the lube from the bedside table and get on my knees behind her. “Are you sure?”
“Yes, please, Cole.”
“Fuck,” Sean groans, pulling away from Nolan. “She’s more than ready. Her ass has been begging for a cock all day.”
“Shut up, Sean,” Chelsea laughs. “I already feel so full.”
“Just wait, Dragonfly.” Kai massages her hips and stops her movements.
I push her down to lie on his chest, and my eyes go to the diamond end of the plug that I can see. I play with it a few times, making her hips chase the movement before pulling it free. I lay it on the bed and slick my cock up, willing myself not to come too soon. I scoot in closer to line up, and her body tenses when she feels the head of my cock against her back hole. “Just relax. I promise we’ll make it feel good. It will burn at first. When you feel me sliding in, push back against me. I’ll go slow.” She takes a deep breath and nods. I place one hand on the base of her spine and use the other to hold my cock at the base. As soon as the head enters her, she tenses again. Kai and I rub her back, whispering soft words until she relaxes against him. I slowly thrust inside her. “Push back,” I grit out. She’s so goddamn tight that it’s taking all my willpower not to slam into her.
She pushes up on Kai’s chest, and I feel her bearing down. My cock pops past the resistance, and her ass feels like it’s sucking me in. My thighs settle against the back of hers, and I stop, giving her time to adjust. Her breathing is out of control, and her fingernails are biting into Kai’s shoulders. “You were such a good girl for me,” I say, rubbing her back. “And you feel so goddamn good.”
“It hurts,” she groans. “You two are too big.”
“Shhh,” Sean comforts, reaching between her and Kai to rub her clit. Her hips jerk, and I have to lock my hands on her hips so I won’t move. “Let them make you feel good.”
Sean rubs her clit until sweet moans are leaving her mouth and her ass is flexing around my dick. “Please move, Cole.” I slide slowly out and watch as I disappear completely inside of her. “Yes,” she breathes, and I know she’s ready.
Kai and I set a steady rhythm, making her moan and whimper with each thrust. I feel eyes on me, so I look over at Axel, and his gaze is flashing between me and Chelsea. When he meets my eyes again, everything that he’s ever hidden from me is written all over his face. It all seems like a waste now, looking back on it. We’ve fought how we felt about each other for so long and missed out on all that time. But now we have a chance to make up for it, and we aren’t going to take it for granted this time.
Chelsea sits up so her back is against my chest. My hand goes around her, plucking and pinching her nipples between my fingers. “You feel so much better than the plug.”
“Fuck,” I groan. “You can’t say stuff like that. I’m trying to go easy on you.”
“I don’t want you to.” She looks at me over her shoulder, and the look on her face takes my breath away. “I want to remember you were here tomorrow. I’m not made of glass.”
“He fucks like a God, Gorgeous. Be careful what you ask for.”
“I want it, Cole. Please?”
I seal my lips over hers, kissing her hard and pushing everything into it. “Brace yourself on his chest,” I whisper against her lips.
Her palms slap down on him, and I grab her hips in a bruising grip. I pull out and slam back inside her, pausing to make sure I didn’t hurt her. “I feel your cock rubbing mine,” Kai groans. His hands slide over mine on her hips, and he holds on tight.
When Chelsea moans deep in her chest, I unleash what I’ve been holding back. I start moving faster and deeper. She keeps up with each thrust without complaint. Kai slides his hand between them to play with her clit and starts fucking her from the bottom. I can hear Axel, Nolan, and Sean beside me, but I can’t take my eyes off where I’m connected to Chelsea. This is more than I ever could have hoped for.
I’m not letting it go now.
Chapter21
Nolan