Page 15 of Sugar Walls (Sweet Treats 5)

Sienna laughs again, throwing her head back with real mirth.

“Oh Natalie. Who would have guessed? You’re such a good girl with your curvy figure and demure ways. But I guess once you get the opportunity, everything changes, hmm? I’m so glad we’re going to be sisters,” she says while leaning over to give me a hug.

I hug her back, giggling a bit myself.

“Well, we’re not actually sisters,” I say, “because you’re dating my dad. So I guess you’re my stepmom? Or a mother figure of sorts?”

At that, both Sienna and I burst out laughing. We’re practically rolling around on the couch because the thought is so funny. Yet, it’s true. We’re bonded because of her relationship with my dad and uncle, and now we’re doubly bonded because we both enjoy the company of two men. Who would have guessed? It’s a filthy scenario, but right up my alley.

“But when will I get a chance to come back?” I say. “When will my initiation be?”

Sienna grins.

“You’ll have to talk with your dad about that one. It’s usually the father who organizes everything on behalf of the daughter. But I’ll let Jack know what happened just now. He’ll be ecstatic!”

With that, we hug again and my heart pounds. I’m so happy about these new developments because I feel like I’ve tapped into a whole new Natalie. This new Natalie is curvy, assertive, and loud as hell when she’s having fun. She enjoys pleasuring two men while squatting nude on a tile bathroom floor. She loves being anonymous, and even more, is looking forward to more sexy times with her two lovers.

7

Natalie

My dad opens the door to our trailer, and steps in. I turn and fix him with a look.

“Jack, you’ve been avoiding me.”

My dad looks sheepish as he puts his bag down.

“Not really.”

I stare pointedly at him again while stirring the soup on the stove.

“No seriously, Daddy. Come on. We both know you’ve been avoiding me.”

My dad sinks into the seat at our little table and buries his head in his hands. Then he runs his big hands through his hair, leaving the strands standing on end. It looks really funny, to be honest. My dad is a handsome guy, but he literally has some hair pointing to the right, some pointing to the left, and some standing straight up.

“Come on Daddy,” I say before spooning out some soup for both of us. I bring the steaming bowls over to the table before going back to the counter to pick up some toasty French bread. I slice off two pieces, and then bring those over to the table as well.

My dad’s eyes brighten when he sees the food.

“Mm, this smells delicious, Natalie,” he says while inhaling deeply. “You’ve really become a great cook.”

I laugh a little.

“No, Dad, I haven’t. I’ve been practicing for a few years now, but I’m still a long ways off from how good Mom was. Now, you can’t avoid me forever. Why have you been avoiding me? Ever since we came back from the Lodge, you’ve either spent all your time with Sienna or you’re off on a job. So what gives?” I ask plaintively. “You were the one who brought me to the Lodge in the first place. I thought you wanted me to like Dads and Daughters.”

My dad puts his head down and sighs.

“Well, I do want you to like Dads and Daughter, Nats. It’s just that … well, Sienna told me what happened and I had no idea you’d like it that much.”

I look at him, my food untouched.

“You mean, she told you I was with two men?”

My dad shakes his head, but then he nods.

“Yes! That wasn’t supposed to happen. You were supposed to be introduced to the club gradually. You were supposed to take a tour, and then maybe witness some debauchery among other people. I didn’t mean for you to be thrust into that situation, much less with two dudes.”

I stare at him.

“How did that happen by the way?”

Jack looks forlorn and runs his hands through his hair again.

“To be honest, Sugar, I’m not sure. I let them know you were coming, and I figured you’d be given the grand tour. But somehow, wires got crossed and a lot more happened than just a tour,” he says ruefully.

“But I liked it!” I chirp, sitting up. “What happened was wonderful, and I enjoyed every second of it.”

My dad won’t look at me for a moment, but then he slides a sideways look in my direction.

“You see, Sugar, that’s the problem. What father wants his daughter to enjoy being with two men? What father wants his daughter to be subjected to glory holes during her first time at the club? What am I doing? Your mom would be so angry.”

I take a deep breath and look him in the eye.

---