Laughing, I tear the package open and make noises of pleasure in the back of my throat. I’m one stiff breeze away from blowing my fucking load and making her lick it up just so I can watch. “Extra-large is a little tight, Tiny Dancer. Next time, I’m gonna need you to shop for the Magnums.”
“Shut up.” Flipping over, she opens her legs and presents her pussy in all its welcoming glory. “Please just hurry up.”
Sliding the condom to my very base, I move back to my knees, pick her up, and toss her back over so I see her ass. She lets out a squeak of surprise, then a mewl of pleasure when I line my cock up and nudge the tip inside her pussy. “No need for foreplay, huh? You’re hot as a fire, babe.”
She pushes back with a moan, but I’m stronger; I’m in control. She wants to swallow me up and get this over with, but I’m not here to use and run. I want it to last, so when she pushes back, I pull back so she has just an inch of me.
Frustrated, she tries to push back. “Dammit, Jay!”
“Patience, beautiful.” I push in another inch and grit my teeth. I’m playing with her, but she’s so fucking tight, I’ve gotta stay in control, or I’ll embarrass myself.
Glancing back toward the filing cabinet, something interesting catches my attention, something shiny and black; it’s too big to be a bullet vibrator, but too small to be a dildo. Reaching across and taking her body with me, she cries out as I snatch up the toy and study it.
Turning the dial at the base, I grin when it starts buzzing in my hands. “Well, well, well. What’ve we got here?”
“That’s mine.”
“I sure hope so. Is it for your pussy or your ass?”
“My pussy,” she pants. Desperately taking advantage of my distraction, with a deep grunt, she pushes back and spears her body until my cock is seated to the base.
“Fuck, Soph!”
“Jesus,” she whimpers. “So big.”
I was obsessed with her toy, but now the tip of my cock touches something deep inside her, and my lungs decide now is a good time to stop working. Dropping the toy on the bed beside my knee, I grab her hips, push her forward, and when she knows what’s coming, when she closes her eyes and latches her teeth onto her own arm, I pull her back and slam in until she cries.
“Oh, God!” Panting, her back lifts and drops as she struggles to breathe. “Oh my God, Jay. Don’t stop.”
“No.” I hold my breath as her tight body squeezes me until I want to weep. “Not stopping, I promise.” Pushing her forward, I drag her back until our thighs slap together and her breath pushes out on an explosive puff. My balls slap her clit; my chest broadens as my lungs oxygenate my body. They struggle to provide me with enough air, but I’ll be damned if I let damage from months ago ruin this for me.
Pushing her forward until my cock is completely free, I hold her with strong hands, line her up, and slam inside until she screams.
“Jesus, Sophia. You’re so fucking tight.” Bringing my hand back, I swing it down and slap her ass until I feel the burn beneath my palm. She cries out as I ride her. Her cry says pain, but her pussy clenches me in a vise until I come to an almost standstill.
“You like that, don’t you?” I swing again and redden the same patch of skin. “Jesus, you’re squeezing me so tight. You love being spanked, you dirty girl.” I smack again, but my hand lands just a little to the side so I don’t hurt her reddened skin.
I want her to feel me; I even want her to feel the pain, but I don’t truly want to hurt her.
Remembering the toy, I pick it up, lean over her, and lubricate her ass with my saliva. “You’re gonna like this, I promise.” She tenses, stiffens, panics, and when her terrified eyes come around to meet mine, I keep her gaze and bring the tip of her toy down to her asshole.
The toy is an inch around, not so big it’ll hurt her. But having me deep inside her pussy while I do this will make her feel full in ways I’m not sure she’s ever known. “Relax, Sophia. Tell me to stop if you want me to stop, but try it first. I promise I’m listening to you; you’re safe. Just say stop.”
Tapping her ass, I grin when her pussy clenches and she lets out a long mewling sound. When she turns back to the top of the bed and drops her head, I slide the toy in an inch and groan when she clenches tight.
Her body spasms. Her ass clenches tight.
Slowly dragging my cock out, I stroke her back and slide the toy in. One inch, then two. I slide my cock back in and groan at how much tighter she is.
“Oh God. Oh God. Oh God.” She fists the blankets and buries her face in the mattress. “Jay…”
“Want me to stop?”
Frantically, she shakes her head.
“Attagirl. You like being naughty, don’t you?” Sliding my cock out again, I nudge the toy another inch in, then, like she’s accepted it, her ass pulls it in until it’s seated deep inside, and her pussy pushes me out. “No way, Sophia Solomon. You need to take both.” Leaving the vibrating plug in her ass, I take her hips and slowly push my cock in. It’s so fucking tight, I swear it can’t possibly work. My cock squeezes, molds, slides into the available space until we’re both breathless. “Jesus fucking hell, Sophia.”
“It’s too much,” she pants. “Too much.”