"You want to keep going?" Theo asked.
"Damn right I do," Seth said, his voice rough. He was getting hard again and more sure than ever that everything Theo did to him could only be good and feel wonderful.
"All this cursing? You're such a bad boy now," Theo teased him.
He got out a condom and Seth knew he was supposed to use it, but he still asked, "Do you have to use that?"
Theo shut his eyes. "Seth," he said through gritted teeth then he slicked up his cock.
"I've never done anything with anyone," Seth told him.
"I always use one," Theo said, the condom still in his hand, his other hand pushing down on the back of Seth's thigh. "And you want me to make an exception for you, trust you?"
"I... No. I was just being selfish. Do it the right way," Seth told him.
"The right way?" Theo said and suddenly his naked cock was at Seth's hole. "Like this?"
Seth's whole body was trembling just at the contact. "Theo," he moaned and felt pressure, nothing like a finger, nothing like anything. It was intense, burning like a hot, steel rod was searing its way inside him. The pain was mingling with a needy ache and a deepening pleasure. Without even knowing it, Seth was moaning the whole time Theo was filling him up.
The long, steady thrust ended, and Theo was tight against him, all the way inside him. Seth couldn't breathe at the feeling of it.
Theo was inside of him, above him, his eyes burning, his body rocking, giving Seth a taste of the fucking he was going to get. The rocking turned into thrusting, slow and deep. Theo was pulling almost all the way out then driving his cock back into the center of him.
"You like it," Theo said. It wasn't a question. Seth was moaning under him so much, shivering, taking his cock like it was a gift.
On the next stroke, Theo pushed all the way then leaned down and kissed him. Seth slid trembling hands down Theo's back and over his ass. He thrust his tongue inside Theo's mouth and felt him start to pump again.
Theo fucked him while they kissed, Seth's cock rubbing against him. Then Theo rose again, gripped Seth by the backs of his knees and was back to doing him deep and slow. It wasn't like before. Seth was closer now, the need to come growing desperate, even more than before when Theo was fingering him and he couldn't contain himself.
Theo's pumping was getting hard, but suddenly he stopped and pulled out. "Turn over," he ordered and Seth obeyed, anything for Theo to let him have it again.
As soon as Seth was on all fours, Theo was in again. Pounding him harder, he was holding onto Seth's hips. The feeling building inside him wouldn't let him hold still. Seth started to rock back, fuck himself on Theo's cock.
He kept to Theo's pace so they slammed together. Theo went faster and harder, and Seth matched him, helped the man fuck him.
Seth's cock was bouncing until Theo wrapped his hand around it, giving him something to thrust into. His cock in Theo's hot grip made him crazy, bucking wildly.
Pleasure was surging hot and powerful from deep inside him until it overtook him and almost knocked him down. He felt Theo's hands grip him harder, marking him. There was no stopping, until Seth was grunting and coming. Then Theo was coming too, calling his name in a strained growl. Theo was unloading inside him and Seth felt like his whole body would shake apart as he screamed, "Yes. Fuck, yes."
Dazed, Seth collapsed and Theo cleaned him up. He stroked Seth's back as he did it like he didn't want to break the connection between them.
"I didn't know it could feel like this. I didn't think anything in the world could feel this good. I didn't want it to ever end," Seth mumbled while reaching for Theo.
But Theo had gone to turn the lamp off and then all they had was moonlight coming in through the window.
"I guess it was good for you," Theo said, his voice husky close by his ear. He was lying down next to him, and Seth hoped he wasn't going anywhere.
"Everything is good with you," Seth said half asleep, happy to feel Theo beside him.
"You'll be sore tomorrow. You might even regret it," Theo said, but that was impossible.
"Not one little bit," Seth said, turned over and pulled him into his arms.
As Theo came to rest against his chest, Seth was afraid to breathe. But then he felt Theo breathing against him – both his chest rising and falling and the heat of his breath on his skin, so Seth started breathing too, timing it to Theo's. He wondered if he could get his heart to beat the same too.
"I'm never going to be able to let you go now," Seth thought as he drifted off, but he wasn't sure if the words made it out.