Cash drops my hand and brushes past Wilder. But Wilder stands rooted in place, his eyes locked on mine.
My eyes prick with tears as I stare at him. An hour ago, I was lying in his arms as he kissed me beneath the shade trees at the creek. Strangers. That's what he's acting like we are now.
"I'm..." I trail off, not knowing what to say.
"Go home, Blondie."
Tears spill out of my eyes as I nod. "I guess I'll see you around."
Wilder takes a step forward and quickly shuts the door behind him. He reaches for my forearm and runs his fingers over the lightning bolt tattoo on my wrist. "Thank you."
"For?" I glance up at him through a haze of tears.
"This," he says as his thumb presses lightly over the tattoo.
I let out a heavy breath before pulling my hand out of his grasp. I leave him standing on his front porch and make my way home.
Cash is back now, which means Wilder, and I are over.
One door is closing while the other is reopening.
The problem is that I want what's behind that closing door, knowing it'll never be mine again.
Chapter 28
The Obnoxious Snorer
Wilder
Cash is sleeping on my floor, his obnoxious snoring keeping me awake. I grab my phone and stare at the time. 3:31 am. At least tomorrow—er, today—is Sunday. I can sleep in.
I take a breath and wince. Every time I breathe in, my heart stings and spasms.
Blondie can find her way home.
Go home, Blondie.
I didn't think breaking her heart would mean breaking my own. But I think that's what I've done.
I toss and turn, shoving another pillow under my head. I'm restless. I've never been this restless before.
All I can think about is Ingrid. I'm not sure when she stopped being Blondie for me. Maybe when I walked in on her recording herself naked. Something happened that day and it changed everything. She's not some nickname anymore. She's Ingrid.
She's Cash's Ingrid.
I wince from the pain again, wishing I could ignore it. Push it away. Pretend long enough to trick my heart into actually believing I feel nothing for her.
Instead, I'm in physical pain. The kind of pain I felt when my dad left. Almost as if a piece of myself has been torn off, and I have to learn how to live without it.
This is all my fault. I knew this would happen. I knew Cash would come back for her. Despite how shitty he's treated her over the years, I know he's never loved anyone like he loves her. That's not an excuse for breaking up with her and ditching her for the summer. It's just a fact.
Cash Allred might be a nice guy, but he's still an Allred. And the Allreds always get what they want in the end.
I should stay out of his way and let him win. I should do that. The thing is, if I can't have Ingrid, then I don't think he should either.
Another loud snore echoes through my room, rattling the windows. I grab one of the pillows I'm propped up on and propel it at Cash's big head.
"What was that for?" he groans loudly.