Sam moaned. “Fuck,” he started laughing. “That’s good.”
I simulated a back and forth motion, fucking him, but the more he moaned, the more jealous I became of the toy which couldn’t appreciate Sam’s ass. I pulled it out. “No more of that.”
“Aw, but it was so much better than you earlier,” he said.
“You mean that?” I asked.
He pouted. “I might need reminding.”
That was a better answer. “Convince me.”
“I’m on PrEP.”
“I figured, Gael and Ash when they set us up, getting regular checks,” I said. “But you don’t need to convince me to hit it raw, just convince me to hit it.”
“I—” he started, his tongue sucking at his teeth. “I liked the way you felt inside me, and if you want me to convince you any further on what you’re missing out on, just put that toy back in me, I’ll ride that, cum, and leave you to play with yourself.”
His sass had a hold of me, my cock in a chokehold twitching and throbbing from every snipe he took. “Ass up.”
He giggled, giddy. “Yes, Sir.”
I spanked him before pulling his cheeks to get full view of his glistening hole, trying its best to appear puckered and tight. The toy had done its job. I slapped the tip of my cock against it like I had earlier this evening, but there wasn’t the same hiding in secret energy that I’d had then, now I was undressed completely, and we were going raw.
Sam begged and pleaded to be fucked, pushing his back up in an attempt to have my cock just slide in him. It almost worked, he was ready, and his ass had been teased enough, it needed a cock. And I still wanted to tease the sass out of him.
“You don’t tell me what to do,” I said, pushing the length of my shaft acorss his ass. “Got it?”
“If you’re not gonna—”
I laid on his back with the force of my entire body, my cock thrusting between his cheeks. “I’m in charge. Say it.” If there was one thing I knew, it was how to get people to say what I wanted them to say. It might take another couple nights until he believed what he was saying. He made me want to put in the work.
“You’re in charge,” he said, still trying in his best attempt at getting my cock to slip inside him. “You’re the boss.”
I kissed the back of his neck. “Good boy.” Pulling my hips back, my cock found his hole with heat seeking precision. I went deep, right for the guts. I’d stopped playing and teasing, I was now more interested in holding his excited horny writhing down with my body.
With long, deep thrusts, shaking his body, Sam let out a deep, intense moan and his hole throbbed around my cock. I knew exactly what that meant, and I didn’t care. I continued to fuck his hole, using the post-orgasm tightness of his hole to squeeze my cock and keep me hard. Like a closed fist, his hole had my cock in a hold, and I wasn’t going to stop fucking it.
I could safely say I’d fucked Sam into submission, his weak moans and whimpers were a symphony on my ears.
“Where do you want it?” I whispered, giving his ear a nibble.
“In me,” he moaned softly. “Cum in me.”
Gripping his hands by his head, I held them, pushing them into the comforter. “Say please.” I couldn’t wait for him to say it. A tingle ran through me, like the start of a leg cramp, it had me jerk against him, and seconds later, I was filling him up.
“Thank you,” he said, his body swelling with deep breaths against mine. “That was just what I needed.”
My cock stayed inside him, and with every motion of his body against mine, I twitched and winced from a strange post-orgasm chill that had turned my body sensitive. It had been a while since that had happened, it was nice. “Just—stay right there,” I said, slowly pulling my hands from the back of his hands. “You wanna stay over?”
He let out a little chuckle, the movement of it was ticklish. “Usually, the dick isn’t still inside me when a guy asks that.”
And he was back to his sassy self. I slowly pulled my cock from his ass. “Then I’ll order you an Uber.” I leaned back and spanked his ass.
“Ugh,” he mumbled. “I’m staying.”
I gave his other cheek a spank. “I thought you might.” I was usually great at aftercare, but I didn’t know how to approach it with him. “You wanna clean up and cuddle?”